Page 647

Chapter 15 Hereditary Fundus Dystrophies

INTRODUCTION 648
INVESTIGATIONS 648
Electroretinography 648
Electro-oculography 649
Dark adaptometry 650
Colour vision tests 650
GENERALIZED PHOTORECEPTOR DYSTROPHIES 651
Typical retinitis pigmentosa 651
Atypical retinitis pigmentosa 654
Important systemic associations 654
Progressive cone dystrophy 656
Leber congenital amaurosis 656
Stargardt disease and fundus flavimaculatus 657
Bietti corneoretinal crystalline dystrophy 660
Alport syndrome 661
Familial benign fleck retina 661
Pigmented paravenous chorioretinal atrophy 661
Congenital stationary night blindness 662
Congenital monochromatism (achromatopsia) 664
MACULAR DYSTROPHIES 665
Juvenile Best macular dystrophy 665
Multifocal vitelliform lesions without Best disease 665
Pattern dystrophy 665
North Carolina macular dystrophy 667
Familial dominant drusen 668
Sorsby pseudoinflammatory dystrophy 669
Benign concentric annular macular dystrophy 669
Central areolar choroidal dystrophy 670
Dominant cystoid macular oedema 670
Sjögren–Larsson syndrome 670
Familial internal limiting membrane dystrophy 670
GENERALIZED CHOROIDAL DYSTROPHIES 670
Choroideremia 670
Gyrate atrophy 671
Generalized choroidal dystrophy 674
Progressive bifocal chorioretinal atrophy 674
VITREORETINAL DYSTROPHIES 674
Juvenile X-linked retinoschisis 674
Stickler syndrome 675
Wagner syndrome 676
Familial exudative vitreoretinopathy 678
Enhanced S-cone syndrome and Goldmann–Favre syndrome 678
Snowflake vitreoretinal degeneration 679
Dominant neovascular inflammatory vitreoretinopathy 679
Dominant vitreoretinochoroidopathy 681
Kniest dysplasia 681
ALBINISM 681
Introduction 681
Tyrosinase-negative oculocutaneous albinism 682
Tyrosinase-positive oculocutaneous albinism 683
Ocular albinism 683
CHERRY-RED SPOT AT MACULA 683
Pathogenesis 683
GM1 gangliosidosis (generalized) 684
Mucolipidosis type I (sialidosis) 684
GM2 gangliosidosis 684
Niemann–Pick disease 684
Farber disease 685
Page 648

Introduction

Applied anatomy

The hereditary fundus dystrophies are a rare but important group of disorders that primarily involve the outer retina (RPE-photoreceptor complex) and its blood supply (choriocapillaris). It is uncommon for the inner retina or the retinal vasculature to be the primary target. There are two types of photoreceptor cells:

1 The rods are the most numerous (120 million) and are of the highest concentration in the mid-peripheral retina. They are most sensitive in dim illumination and are responsible for night and peripheral vision. If rod dysfunction occurs earlier or is more severe than cone dysfunction, it will result in poor night vision (nyctalopia) and peripheral field loss, the former usually occurring first.
2 The cones are fewer in number (6 million) and have their highest concentration at the fovea. They are most sensitive in bright light and mediate day vision, colour vision and central visual acuity. Cone dysfunction therefore results in poor central vision, impairment of colour vision (dyschromatopsia) and occasionally problems with day vision (hemeralopia).

Inheritance

1 Autosomal dominant (AD) dystrophies often manifest more variable expression, have a later onset and a milder course as compared with recessive disorders.
2 Recessive dystrophies may be autosomal (AR) or X-linked (XL). They have an earlier onset and more severe course that AD dystrophies. In some cases female carriers of XL conditions show characteristic fundus findings (see below).
3 X-linked dominant conditions are extremely rare and typically lethal in boys (e.g. Aicardi syndrome).

Classification

The dystrophies can be subdivided into two main groups: (a) generalized which involve the entire fundus and (b) local in which only the macula is affected. Further subclassification of each is based on the presumed site of primary pathology (e.g. photoreceptors, RPE or choroid).

Investigations

Electroretinography

Principles

The electroretinogram (ERG) is the record of an action potential produced by the retina when it is stimulated by light of adequate intensity. The recording is made between an active electrode either in contact with the cornea or a skin electrode placed just below the lower eyelid margin, and a reference electrode on the forehead. The potential between the two electrodes is then amplified and displayed (Fig. 15.1). The normal ERG is biphasic (Fig. 15.2).

1 The a-wave is the initial fast negative deflection generated by photoreceptors.
Page 649
2 The b-wave is the next slower positive large amplitude deflection. Although it is generated from fluxes of potassium ions within and surrounding Müller cells, it is directly dependent on functional photoreceptors and its magnitude makes it a convenient measure of photoreceptor integrity. The amplitude of the b-wave is measured from the trough of the a-wave to the peak of the b-wave. It is enhanced with dark adaptation and increased light stimulus. The b-wave consists of b-1 and b-2 subcomponents; the former probably represents both rod and cone activity and the latter mainly cone activity. It is possible to single out rod and cone responses with special techniques.
image

Fig. 15.1 Principles of electroretinography

image

Fig. 15.2 Components and origins of the electroretinogram

Standard ERG

The normal ERG consists of five recordings (Fig. 15.3). The first three are elicited after 30 minutes of dark adaptation (scotopic), and the last two after 10 minutes of adaptation to moderately bright diffuse illumination (photopic). It may be difficult to dark adapt children for 30 minutes and therefore dim light (mesopic) conditions can be utilized to evoke predominantly rod-mediated responses to low intensity white or blue light stimuli.

1 Scotopic ERG
a Rod responses are elicited with a very dim flash of white or blue light, resulting in a large b-wave and a small or non-recordable a-wave.
b Combined rod and cone responses are elicited with a very bright white flash, resulting in a prominent a-wave and b-wave.
c Oscillatory potentials are elicited by using a bright flash and changing the recording parameters. The oscillatory wavelets occur on the ascending limb of the b-wave and are generated by cells in the inner retina.
2 Photopic ERG
a Cone responses are elicited with a single bright flash, resulting in an a-wave and a b-wave with small oscillations.
b Cone flicker is used to isolate cones by using a flickering light stimulus at a frequency of 30 Hz to which rods cannot respond. It provides a measure of the amplitude and implicit time of the cone b-wave. Cone responses can be elicited in normal eyes up to 50 Hz, after which point individual responses are no longer recordable (‘critical flicker fusion’).
image

Fig. 15.3 Normal electroretinographic recordings

Multifocal ERG

Multifocal ERG is a method of producing topographical maps of retinal function (Fig. 15.4). The stimulus is scaled for variation in photoreceptor density across the retina. At the fovea, where the density of receptors is high, a lesser stimulus is used than in the periphery where receptor density is lower. As with conventional ERG, many types of measurements can be made. Both the amplitude and timing of the troughs and peaks can be measured and reported and the information can be summarized in the form of a three-dimensional plot which resembles the hill of vision. The technique can be used for almost any disorder which affects retinal function.

image

Fig. 15.4 Multifocal electroretinogram

Electro-oculography

1 Principle. The electro-oculogram (EOG) measures the standing potential between the electrically positive cornea and the electrically negative back of the eye (Fig. 15.5). It reflects the activity of the RPE and the photoreceptors. This means that an eye blinded by lesions proximal to the photoreceptors will have a normal EOG. In general, diffuse or widespread disease of the RPE is needed to significantly affect the response.
2 Interpretation. As there is much variation in EOG amplitude in normal subjects, the result is calculated by dividing the maximal height of the potential in the light (‘light peak’) by the minimal height of the potential in the dark (‘dark trough’). This is expressed as a ratio (Arden ratio) or as a percentage. The normal value is over 1.85 or 185%.
Page 650
image

Fig. 15.5 Principles of electro-oculography

Dark adaptometry

1 Principle. Dark adaptation (DA) is the phenomenon by which the visual system (pupil, retina and occipital cortex) adapts to decreased illumination. This test is particularly useful in the investigation of nyctalopia. The retina is exposed to an intense light for a time sufficient to bleach 25% or more of the rhodopsin in the retina. Following this, normal rods are insensitive to light and cones respond only to very bright stimuli. Subsequent recovery of light sensitivity can be monitored by placing the subject in the dark and periodically presenting spots of light of varying intensity in the visual field and asking the subject if they are perceived.
2 Technique of Goldmann–Weekes adaptometry
a The subject is exposed to an intense light that bleaches the photoreceptors and then is suddenly placed in the dark.
b The threshold at which the subject just perceives a light is plotted.
c The flashes are repeated at regular intervals; the sensitivity of the eye to light gradually increases.
3 The sensitivity curve is a bipartite plot of the light intensity of a minimally perceived spot versus time (Fig. 15.6).
a The cone branch of the curve represents the initial 5–10 minutes of darkness during which cone sensitivity rapidly improves. The rod photoreceptors are also recovering but more slowly during this time.
b The ‘rod-cone’ break normally occurs after 7–10 minutes when cones achieve their maximum sensitivity, and the rods become perceptibly more sensitive than cones.
c The rod branch of the curve is slower and represents the continuation of improvement of rod sensitivity. After 15–30 minutes, the fully dark-adapted rods allow the subject to perceive a spot of light over 100 times dimmer than would be possible with cones alone. If the flashes are focused onto the foveola (where rods are absent), only a rapid segment corresponding to cone adaptation is recorded.
image

Fig. 15.6 Dark adaptation curve

Colour vision tests

Colour vision (CV) testing is sometimes useful in the clinical evaluation of hereditary fundus dystrophies, where dyschromatopsia may be present prior to the development of impairment of visual acuity and visual field loss.

Principles

CV is a function of three populations of retinal cones each with its specific sensitivity; blue (tritan) at 414–424 nm, green (deuteran) 522–539 nm and red (protan) at 549–570 nm.

A normal person requires all these primary colours to match those within the spectrum. Any given cone pigment may be deficient (e.g. protanomaly – red weakness) or entirely absent (e.g. protanopia – red blindness). Trichromats possess all three types of cones (although not necessarily functioning perfectly), while absence of one or two types of cones renders an individual a dichromat or a monochromat respectively.
Most individuals with congenital colour defects are anomalous trichromats and use abnormal proportions of the three primary colours to match those in the light spectrum.
Page 651
Those with red-green deficiency caused by abnormality of red-sensitive cones are protanomalous, those with abnormality of green-sensitive cones are deuteranomalous and those with blue-green deficiency caused by abnormality of blue-sensitive cones are tritanomalous. Acquired macular disease tends to produce blue-yellow defects and optic nerve lesions red-green defects.

Colour vision tests

1 Ishihara test is used mainly to screen for congenital protan and deuteran defects. It consists of a test plate followed by sixteen plates each with a matrix of dots arranged to show a central shape or number which the subject is asked to identify (Fig. 15.7A). A colour deficient person will only be able to identify some of the figures. Inability to identify the test plate (provided visual acuity is sufficient) indicates non-organic visual loss.
2 Hardy–Rand–Rittler is similar to Ishihara but more sensitive since it can detect all three congenital colour defects (Fig. 15.7B).
3 City University test consists of 10 plates each containing a central colour and four peripheral colours (Fig. 15.7C). The subject selects the peripheral colours which most closely matches the central colour.
4 Farnsworth–Munsell 100-hue is the most sensitive for both congenital and acquired colour defects but is seldom used in clinical practice. Despite the name it consists of 85 hue caps contained in four separate racks in each of which the two end caps are fixed while the others are loose so they can be randomized by the examiner (Fig. 15.7D).
a The subject is asked to rearrange the loose randomized caps ‘in their natural’ order in one box.
b The box is then closed, turned upside down and then opened so that the markers on the inside of the caps become visible.
c The findings are then recorded in a simple cumulative manner on a circular chart.
d Each of the three forms of dichromatism is characterized by failure in a specific meridian of the chart (Fig. 15.8).
5 Farnsworth D15 hue discrimination test is similar to the Farnsworth–Munsell 100-hue test but utilizes only 15 caps.
image

Fig. 15.7 Colour vision tests. (A) Ishihara; (B) Hardy–Rand–Rittler; (C) City University; (D) Farnsworth-Munsell 100-hue test

(Courtesy of T Waggoner – fig. B)

image

Fig. 15.8 Farnsworth–Munsell test results of colour deficiencies. (A) Protan; (B) deuteran; (C) tritan

Generalized photoreceptor dystrophies

Typical retinitis pigmentosa

Retinitis pigmentosa (RP) defines a clinically and genetically diverse group of diffuse retinal dystrophies initially predominantly affecting the rod photoreceptor cells with subsequent degeneration of cones (rod-cone dystrophy). It is the most commonly encountered hereditary fundus dystrophy with a prevalence of approximately 1 : 5000.

Inheritance

The age of onset, rate of progression, eventual visual loss and associated ocular features are frequently related to the mode of inheritance. RP may occur as an isolated sporadic disorder, or be inherited as AD, AR or XL. Many cases are due to mutation of the rhodopsin gene. XL is the least common but most severe form and may result in complete blindness by the third or fourth decades. Female carriers may have normal fundi or show a golden-metallic (’tapetal’) reflex at the macula (Fig. 15.9A) and/or small peripheral patches of bone-spicule pigmentation (Fig. 15.9B). RP, often atypical, may also be associated with systemic disorders which are usually AR (see below).

Page 652
image

Fig. 15.9 Findings in carriers of XL retinitis pigmentosa. (A) ‘Tapetal’ reflex at the macula; (B) mild peripheral pigmentary changes

(Courtesy of D Taylor and CS Hoyt, from Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus, Elsevier, Saunders, 2005 – fig. A)

Diagnosis

The diagnostic criteria for RP comprise bilateral involvement, with loss of peripheral and night vision. The classical triad of RP is: (a) arteriolar attenuation, (b) retinal bone-spicule pigmentation and (c) waxy disc pallor.

1 Presentation is with nyctalopia, often during the 2nd–3rd decades, though may be earlier or later, depending on the pedigree.
2 Signs in chronological order:
Subtle mid-peripheral RPE atrophy associated with mild arteriolar narrowing, and mid-peripheral intraretinal perivascular ‘bone-spicule’ pigmentary changes (Fig. 15.10A).
Gradual increase in density of the pigmentary changes with anterior and posterior spread (Fig. 15.10B).
Tessellated fundus appearance, due to RPE atrophy and unmasking of large choroidal vessels (Fig. 15.10C).
Severe arteriolar narrowing and gliotic ‘waxy pallor’ of the optic discs (Fig. 15.10D).
The macula may show atrophy, epiretinal membrane formation and CMO; the latter may respond to systemic acetazolamide.
3 ERG in early disease shows reduced scotopic rod and combined responses (Fig. 15.11); later photopic responses become reduced and eventually the ERG becomes extinguished.
4 EOG is subnormal with an absence of the light rise.
5 DA is prolonged and may be useful in early cases where the diagnosis is uncertain.
6 Perimetry initially demonstrates small mid-peripheral scotomas that gradually coalesce to form the classical annular scotoma, which expands both peripherally and centrally. It ultimately leaves a tiny island of central vision which may eventually be extinguished. Perimetry is useful in monitoring the progression of disease.
7 Prognosis is variable and tends to be associated with the mode of inheritance as follows:
XL disease has the worst prognosis with severe visual loss by the 4th decade.
AR disease and sporadic cases have a more favourable prognosis with retention of central vision until the 5th–6th decade or later.
AD disease generally has the best prognosis with retention of central vision beyond the 6th decade.
image

Fig. 15.10 Progression of retinitis pigmentosa. (A) Early changes; (B) advanced changes; (C) unmasking of choroidal vessels; (D) end-stage disease

(Courtesy of P Saine – fig. A)

image

Fig. 15.11 ERG in early retinitis pigmentosa shows reduced scotopic rod and combined responses

Ocular associations

Regular follow-up of patients with RP is essential to detect other vision-threatening complications, some of which may be amenable to treatment.

1 Posterior subcapsular cataracts are common in all forms of RP; surgery is often beneficial.
2 Open-angle glaucoma occurs in 3% of cases.
3 Myopia is common.
4 Keratoconus is uncommon.
5 Vitreous changes, which are common, consist of posterior vitreous detachment and occasionally intermediate uveitis.
6 Optic disc drusen occur more frequently in patients with RP.
7 Coats-like disease with lipid deposition in the peripheral retina and exudative retinal detachment (Fig. 15.12) may occasionally develop in adult life.
image

Fig. 15.12 Coats-like features associated with retinitis pigmentosa

Atypical retinitis pigmentosa

Atypical RP describes conditions that are closely related to typical RP or represent incomplete forms of the disease.

1 Cone-rod dystrophy in which the cone component is affected earlier and more severely than in typical RP. Presentation is with impairment of central vision and not with nyctalopia. Examination may show a macular lesion with or without peripheral changes.
2 RP sine pigmento is characterized by absence or paucity of pigment accumulation (Fig. 15.13A), which may subsequently appear with time.
3 Retinitis punctata albescens is an AR variant characterized by scattered whitish-yellow spots, most numerous at the equator, usually sparing the macula, and associated with arteriolar attenuation (Fig. 15.13B). They are similar to the spots in fundus albipunctatus but often have a more radial pattern.
4 Sector RP is an AD variant characterized by involvement of inferior quadrants (Fig. 15.13C). Progression is slow and many cases are stationary.
image

Fig. 15.13 Atypical retinitis pigmentosa. (A) Sine pigmento; (B) retinitis punctata albescens; (C) sector

Important systemic associations

Bassen–Kornzweig syndrome (abetalipoproteinaemia)

1 Inheritance is AR.
2 Pathogenesis. Deficiency of chylomycrons and low-density lipoproteins results in malabsorption of fat-soluble vitamins A, E and occasionally K.
3 Systemic features
Failure to thrive and steatorrhea in infancy followed by severe spinocerebellar ataxia.
Blood shows ‘thorny’ red cells (acanthocytosis) and low plasma cholesterol and triglycerides.
4 Fundus shows scattered white dots followed by RP-like changes developing towards the end of the 1st decade. Treatment with large doses of vitamin A and E may prevent visual loss.
5 Other ocular features include ptosis, ophthalmoplegia, strabismus and nystagmus.

Refsum disease

1 Inheritance is AR. The infantile and adult forms are genetically distinct.
2 Pathogenesis. Deficiency in phytanic acid alpha-hydrolase results in accumulation of phytanic acid throughout the body. Early detection and treatment with a diet low in phytanic acid can arrest disease progression.
3 Systemic features
a Infantile disease is characterized by dysmorphic facies, mental handicap, hepatomegaly and deafness.
b Adult disease is characterized by cerebellar ataxia, polyneuropathy, anosmia, deafness, cardiomyopathy and ichthyosis (Fig. 15.14B).
4 Fundus appearance may be similar to RP or merely show salt-and-pepper changes.
5 Other ocular features include cataract, prominent corneal nerves, optic atrophy, nystagmus and poorly dilating pupils.
image

Fig. 15.14 Selected systemic associations of retinitis pigmentosa. (A) Acanthocytosis in Bassen–Kornzweig syndrome; (B) ichthyosis in adult Refsum disease; (C) ptosis in Kearns–Sayre syndrome; (D) polydactyly in Bardet–Biedl syndrome

Kearns–Sayre syndrome

Page 655

Kearns–Sayre syndrome is characterized by chronic progressive external ophthalmoplegia (Fig. 15.14C) associated with other systemic problems, which are described in Chapter 19. The fundus usually has a ‘salt and pepper’ appearance most striking at the macula; less frequently findings are typical RP or choroidal atrophy similar to choroideremia.

Bardet–Biedl syndrome

1 Inheritance is genetically heterogeneous.
2 Systemic features include hypogonadism in males, polydactyly (Fig. 15.14D), truncal obesity, renal anomalies and mental handicap.
3 Fundus typically shows a bull’s eye maculopathy due to cone-rod dystrophy. Less frequently findings are typical RP, RP sine pigmento and retinitis punctata albescens. Although only 15% of patients show retinopathy by 10 years of age, almost 80% are blind by the age of 20 years.

Usher syndrome

Usher syndrome is a distressing condition which accounts for about 5% of all cases of profound deafness in children, and is responsible for about half of all cases of combined deafness and blindness. There are three major types in which sensorineural deafness is associated with typical RP with or without vestibular dysfunction.

1 Inheritance is AR (genetically heterogeneous).
2 Classification
a Type I (75% of patients) – congenital, profound deafness with vestibular dysfunction; visual loss due to RP with extinguished ERG occurs in the 1st decade.
b Type II (23%) – congenital, moderate to severe deafness with normal vestibular function; visual loss occurs in the 2nd decade.
c Type III (2%) – progressive hearing loss and progressive vestibular dysfunction and relatively late-onset pigmentary retinopathy.
3 Systemic features include premature ageing beginning in infancy, dwarfism, skeletal anomalies, deafness, photosensitivity, mental handicap and early demise.
4 Fundus shows salt and pepper pigmentation and optic atrophy.
5 Other ocular features are miosis, cataract and orbital fat atrophy.
Page 656

Progressive cone dystrophy

Progressive cone dystrophy predominantly affects the cone system. In some cases there is no evidence of rod dysfunction whilst in others rod dysfunction subsequently develops but cone deficiency still predominates (cone-rod dystrophy).

1 Inheritance. Most cases are sporadic; the remainder are AD or XL.
2 Presentation is in the 2nd–4th decades with gradual bilateral impairment of central and colour vision which may be followed by photophobia.
3 Signs in chronological order:
The macula may be virtually normal or show non-specific pigmentary changes (Fig. 15.15A).
A golden sheen may be seen in XL disease (Fig. 15.15B).
A bull’s eye maculopathy is classically described but is not universal (Fig. 15.15C); other causes of a bull’s eye appearance are given in Table 15.1.
Progressive RPE atrophy at the macula with eventual geographic atrophy (Fig. 15.15D).
4 ERG. Photopic responses are subnormal or non-recordable and flicker fusion frequency is reduced, but rod responses are preserved until late (Fig. 15.16).
5 EOG is normal to subnormal.
6 DA. The cone segment is abnormal. The rod segment is initially normal but may become subnormal later.
7 CV shows a severe deuteran-tritan defect out of proportion to visual acuity.
8 FA of bull’s eye maculopathy shows a round hyperfluorescent window defect with a hypofluorescent centre (Fig. 15.17).
9 Prognosis is poor with eventual severe loss of central vision to the level of 6/60 or CF.
image

Fig. 15.15 Progressive cone dystrophy. (A) Early pigment mottling; (B) Golden sheen in XL disease; (C) ‘bull’s eye’ maculopathy; (D) geographic atrophy

(Courtesy of Moorfields Eye Hospital – fig. A)

Table 15.1 Other causes of bull’s eye macula

1 In adults
Chloroquine maculopathy
Advanced Stargardt disease
Fenestrated sheen macular dystrophy
Benign concentric annular macular dystrophy
Clofazimine retinopathy
2 In children
Bardet–Biedl syndrome
Hallervorden-Spatz syndrome
Leber congenital amaurosis
Lipofuscinosis
AD cerebellar ataxia
image

Fig. 15.16 ERG in progressive cone dystrophy shows reduced photopic responses and flicker fusion frequency

image

Fig. 15.17 Bull’s eye maculopathy. (A and B) Clinical appearance; (C and D) appearance on FA

Leber congenital amaurosis

Leber congenital amaurosis is a severe rod-cone dystrophy that is the commonest genetic cause of visual impairment in infants and children. It carries a very poor prognosis.

Page 657
1 Inheritance is usually AR. It is genetically heterogeneous, with at least 14 gene loci identified.
2 Presentation is with blindness at birth, or shortly thereafter, associated with roving eye movements or nystagmus.
3 Signs are variable and include the following:
The pupillary light reflexes are absent or diminished.
The fundi may be normal initially apart from mild arteriolar narrowing.
Mild peripheral pigmentary retinopathy (Fig. 15.18A), salt and pepper changes, and less frequently yellow flecks.
Severe macular pigmentation (Fig. 15.18B) or coloboma-like atrophy (Fig. 15.18C).
Pigmentary retinopathy, optic atrophy and severe arteriolar narrowing in later childhood.
Disc elevation is uncommon.
Oculodigital syndrome in which constant rubbing of the eyes by the child causes enophthalmos as the result of atrophy of orbital fat (Fig. 15.18D).
4 Ocular associations include strabismus, hypermetropia, keratoconus, keratoglobus and cataract.
5 ERG is usually non-recordable even in early cases with normal-appearing fundi.
6 Systemic associations include mental handicap, deafness, epilepsy, CNS and renal anomalies, skeletal malformations and endocrine dysfunction.
image

Fig. 15.18 Leber congenital amaurosis. (A) Mild pigmentary retinopathy; (B) macular pigmentation and optic disc drusen; (C) macular coloboma-like atrophy; (D) oculodigital syndrome

(Courtesy of A Moore – figs A-C; N Rogers – fig. D)

Stargardt disease and fundus flavimaculatus

Stargardt disease (juvenile macular dystrophy) and fundus flavimaculatus (FFM) are regarded as variants of the same disease despite presenting at different times and carrying different prognoses. The condition is characterized by diffuse accumulation of lipofuscin within the RPE that results in vermilion fundus and a ‘dark choroid’ seen on FA (see below).

1 Inheritance is AR. Mutations in at least three different genes have been identified as causing Stargardt disease, including ABCA4, and at least two, again including ABCA4, for FFM.
Page 658
Page 659
2 Presentation is in the 1st–2nd decades with bilateral gradual impairment of central vision which may be out of proportion to the macular changes, so that the child may be suspected of malingering. Some patients present in adult life, although in the absence of macular involvement the condition may remain asymptomatic for many years and discovered by chance.
3 Macula may show the following:
May be initially normal or show non-specific mottling (Fig. 15.19A).
An oval ‘snail-slime’ or ‘beaten-bronze’ appearance (Fig. 15.19B).
Geographic atrophy that may have a bull’s eye configuration (Fig. 15.19C).
4 Flecks have the following characteristics;
Bilateral yellow-white lesions at the level of the RPE; of various size and shape, such as round, oval or pisciform (fish-shaped).
Distribution may be at the posterior pole exclusively or extending to the mid-periphery (Fig. 15.19D).
New lesions develop as older ones become ill-defined and softer.
5 Prognosis of maculopathy is poor; once visual acuity drops below 6/12 it tends to decrease rapidly and stabilize at about 6/60. Patients with only flecks have a relatively good prognosis and may remain asymptomatic for many years until the development of macular disease. A small minority develop CNV which carries a very poor prognosis.
Page 660
6 ERG. Photopic is normal to subnormal and scotopic is normal.
7 EOG is subnormal in advanced cases.
8 FA
Maculopathy shows hyperfluorescence due to a window defect often associated with a generalized ‘dark choroid’ with prominence of the retinal vasculature (Fig. 15.20A).
Fresh flecks show early hypofluorescence due to blockage and late hyperfluorescence due to staining; old flecks show RPE window defects (Fig. 15.20B).
9 ICGA shows hypofluorescent spots (Fig. 15.20C).
10 Autofluorescence may be present (Fig. 15.20D).
image

Fig. 15.19 Stargardt disease/fundus flavimaculatus. (A) Nonspecific macular mottling; (B) ‘snail slime’ maculopathy surrounded by flecks; (C) bull’s eye maculopathy surrounded by flecks; (D) diffuse flecks

image

Fig. 15.20 Imaging in Stargardt disease/fundus flavimaculatus. (A) FA shows macular hyperfluorescence and a ‘dark’ choroid; (B) FA shows hyperfluorescent spots; (C) ICGA shows hypofluorescent spots

(Courtesy of A Bolton – fig. C)

Bietti corneoretinal crystalline dystrophy

Bietti dystrophy is characterized by deposition of crystals in the retina and the superficial peripheral cornea. It is much more common in East Asians, particularly Chinese, than other ethnicities.

1 Inheritance is AR with the gene locus on 4q35 (CYP4VZ gene).
2 Presentation is in the 3rd–4th decades with slowly progressive visual loss.
3 Signs in chronological order:
Numerous, fine, glistening, yellow-white crystals, located in all layers of the retina, scattered throughout the posterior fundus (Fig. 15.21A).
Localized atrophy of the RPE and choriocapillaris at the macula.
Diffuse atrophy of the choriocapillaris with a decrease in size and number of the crystals.
Gradual confluence and expansion of the atrophic areas into the periphery.
Diffuse chorioretinal atrophy in end-stage disease.
4 ERG is subnormal.
5 FA shows characteristic large hypofluorescent patches with intact overlying retinal vessels (Fig. 15.21B).
6 Prognosis is variable because the rate of disease progression differs in individual cases.
Page 661
image

Fig. 15.21 (A) Bietti corneoretinal crystalline dystrophy; (B) FA shows hypofluorescent patches

Alport syndrome

1 Pathogenesis. Alport syndrome is a rare abnormality of glomerular basement membrane caused by mutations in several different genes, all of which encode particular forms of type IV collagen, a major component of basement membrane. It is characterized by chronic renal failure, often associated with sensorineural deafness.
2 Inheritance is predominantly XL.
3 Signs
Scattered, yellowish, punctate flecks in the perimacular area with normal visual acuity (Fig. 15.22A).
Larger peripheral flecks, some of which may become confluent (Fig. 15.22B).
4 ERG is normal.
5 Ocular associations are anterior lenticonus and occasionally posterior polymorphous corneal dystrophy.
6 Prognosis for vision is excellent.
image

Fig. 15.22 Alport syndrome. (A) Perimacular flecks; (B) peripheral flecks

(Courtesy of J Govan)

Familial benign fleck retina

Familial benign fleck retina is a very rare disorder which is asymptomatic and therefore usually discovered by chance.

1 Inheritance is AR.
2 Signs. Widespread, discrete, yellow-white, polymorphous shapes which spare the fovea and extend to the far periphery (Fig. 15.23).
3 ERG is normal.
4 Prognosis is excellent.
image

Fig. 15.23 Benign familial fleck retina

Pigmented paravenous chorioretinal atrophy

Paravenous chorioretinal atrophy is an innocuous and asymptomatic condition that is usually non-progressive. The fundus changes are bilaterally symmetric.

Page 662
1 Inheritance is predominantly AD and can be caused by mutations in the CRB1 gene (lq31–q).
2 Signs
Sharply outlined zones of chorioretinal atrophy that follow the course of the major retinal veins and may also encircle the optic disc.
Paravenous bone-spicule pigmentation (Fig. 15.24).
Optic disc and retinal vascular calibre are usually normal.
3 ERG is normal.
image

Fig. 15.24 Pigmented paravenous retinochoroidal atrophy

(Courtesy of C Barry)

Congenital stationary night blindness

Congenital stationary night blindness (CSNB) refers to a group of disorders characterized by infantile onset nyctalopia and non-progressive retinal dysfunction. The fundus appearance may be normal or abnormal.

With normal fundus

CSNB with a normal fundus appearance is sometimes classified into type 1 (complete) and type 2 (incomplete) forms. The former is characterized by complete absence of rod pathway function and essentially normal cone function clinically and on ERG, the latter has impairment with both rod and cone function. Mutations in numerous genes have been identified as causing the CSNB phenotype, with XL, AD and AR inheritance patterns.

With abnormal fundus

1 Oguchi disease is a very rare AR condition.
The fundus has an unusual golden-yellow colour in the light-adapted state (Fig. 15.25A) which becomes normal after prolonged dark adaptation (Mizuo phenomenon – Fig 15.25B).
Rod function is absent after 30 minutes of dark adaptation but recovers to a near-normal level after a long period of dark adaptation.
2 Fundus albipunctatus is an innocuous AR or AD condition.
The fundus shows a multitude of subtle, tiny yellow-white spots at the posterior pole, sparing the fovea and extending to the periphery (Fig. 15.26A).
The retinal blood vessels, optic disc, peripheral fields and visual acuity remain normal.
FA shows mottled hyperfluorescence, except at the fovea, indicating depigmentation of the RPE (Fig. 15.26B).
image

Fig. 15.25 Mizuo phenomenon in Oguchi disease. (A) In the light-adapted state; (B) in the dark-adapted state

(Courtesy of J Donald M Gass, from Stereoscopic Atlas of Macular Diseases, Mosby, 1997)

image

Fig. 15.26 Fundus albipunctatus. (A) Clinical appearance; (B) FA shows mottled hyperfluorescence

(Courtesy of C Barry)

Congenital monochromatism (achromatopsia)

Rod monochromatism (complete achromatopsia)

1 Inheritance is AR.
2 Signs
VA is 6/60.
Macula usually appears normal but may be hypoplastic.
Congenital nystagmus and photophobia.
3 ERG. Photopic abnormal; scotopic may be subnormal; flicker fusion <30HZ.
Page 665
4 CV is totally absent, all colours appearing as shades of grey.

Blue cone monochromatism (incomplete achromatopsia)

1 Inheritance is XL.
2 Signs
VA is 6/6–6/9.
Normal macula.
Nystagmus and photophobia are absent.
3 ERG is normal except for absence of cone responses to red and white light.
4 CV is totally absent.

Macular dystrophies

Juvenile Best macular dystrophy

Best (vitelliform) macular dystrophy is the second most common macular dystrophy.

1 Inheritance is AD with variable penetrance and expressivity with the gene locus on 11q13 (BEST1 gene).
2 Signs evolve gradually through the following stages:
a Pre-vitelliform is characterized by a subnormal EOG in an asymptomatic child with a normal fundus.
b Vitelliform develops in infancy or early childhood and does not usually impair vision.
A round, sharply-delineated (‘sunny side up egg yolk’) macular lesion within the RPE that varies in size between half a disc and two disc diameters (Fig. 15.27A).
FA shows corresponding hypofluorescence due to blockage (Fig. 15.27B).
OCT shows material within the RPE (Fig. 15.27C).
The size of the lesions and stage of development in the two eyes may be asymmetrical and occasionally only one eye is initially involved.
Occasionally the condition may be extramacular and multiple (Fig. 15.27D).
c Pseudohypopyon may occur at puberty when part of the lesion becomes resorbed (Fig. 15.27E).
d Vitelliruptive in which the egg yolk begins to break up (’scramble’) and visual acuity drops (Fig. 15.27F).
e Atrophic in which all pigment has disappeared leaving an atrophic area of RPE.
3 EOG is severely subnormal during all stages and also abnormal in carriers with normal fundi.
4 Prognosis is reasonably good until the 5th decade after which visual acuity declines in one or both eyes due to CNV, scarring or geographic atrophy.
image

Fig. 15.27 Juvenile Best macular dystrophy. (A) Vitelliform stage; (B) FA shows hypofluorescence due to blocked background choroidal fluorescence; (C) OCT shows material within the RPE; (D) multifocal disease; (E) pseudohypopyon stage; (F) vitelliruptive stage

(Courtesy of C Barry – fig. C)

Multifocal vitelliform lesions without Best disease

Occasionally multifocal vitelliform lesions (Fig. 15.28), identical to those in Best disease, may become manifest in adult life and give rise to diagnostic problems. However, in these patients the EOG is normal and the family history is negative. Occasionally Best dystrophy may present with multifocal lesions.

image

Fig. 15.28 Multifocal vitelliform lesions

(Courtesy of C Barry)

Pattern dystrophy

Pattern dystrophy is a generic term that encompasses several retinal dystrophies exhibiting yellow, orange or grey deposits at the macula that have a variety of morphologies. The lesions are associated with the accumulation of lipofuscin at the level of the RPE. Pattern dystrophy is usually present in isolation but has also been described in patients with myotonic dystrophy, Kjellin syndrome (spastic paraplegia and dementia) and pseudoxanthoma elasticum. The main phenotypes having the following common characteristics are discussed below: (a) AD inheritance, (b) variable expressivity, (c) bilateral symmetrical involvement, (d) relatively benign course and (e) normal ERG but occasionally abnormal EOG.

Adult-onset macular vitelliform dystrophy

In contrast to juvenile Best disease, the foveal lesions are smaller, present later and do not demonstrate similar evolutionary changes.

1 Inheritance. It is caused by mutation in the RDS gene on chromosome 6p, as well as the BEST1 gene in common with juvenile-onset Best dystrophy.
2 Presentation is in the 4th–6th decades with mild to moderate decrease in visual acuity and sometimes metamorphopsia although often the condition is discovered by chance.
3 Signs
Bilateral, symmetrical, round or oval, slightly elevated yellowish subfoveal deposit, about one-third of a disc diameter in size, often centered by a pigmented spot (Fig. 15.29A).
Associated macular drusen may be seen in some cases.
4 FA shows central hypofluorescence surrounded by a small irregular hyperfluorescent ring (Fig. 15.29B).
image

Fig. 15.29 (A) Adult-onset macular vitelliform dystrophy; (B) FA shows corresponding hyperfluorescence

Butterfly-shaped macular dystrophy

1 Inheritance is AD.
2 Presentation is in the 2nd–3rd decades usually by chance and occasionally with mild impairment of central vision.
3 Signs
Yellow pigment at the fovea arranged in a triradiate manner (Fig. 15.30A).
Peripheral pigmentary stippling may be present.
Atrophic maculopathy may occasionally develop with time.
4 FA shows non-fluorescence of the lesions outlined by hyperfluorescence (Fig. 15.30B).
image

Fig. 15.30 (A) Butterfly dystrophy; (B) FA shows non-fluorescence of the lesion outlined by hyperfluorescence

(Courtesy of Moorfields Eye Hospital)

Multifocal pattern dystrophy simulating fundus flavimaculatus

1 Presentation is in the 4th decade with mild impairment of central vision.
Page 666
Page 667
2 Signs multiple, widely-scattered, irregular, yellow lesions that may be similar to those seen in fundus flavimaculatus (Fig. 15.31A).
3 FA shows hyperfluorescence of flecks but the choroid is not dark (Fig. 15.31B).
image

Fig. 15.31 (A) Multifocal pattern dystrophy simulating fundus flavimaculatus; (B) FA shows hyperfluorescence but the choroid is not dark

(Courtesy of S Milewski)

Macroreticular pattern dystrophy

1 Presentation is in early childhood.
2 Signs
Initially pigment granules at the fovea.
Reticular pigmentation develops that spreads to the periphery.
3 FA enhances the characteristic macular changes (Fig. 15.32).
image

Fig. 15.32 FA of macroreticular pattern dystrophy

(Courtesy of RF Spaide, from Diseases of the Retina and Vitreous, WB Saunders, 1999)

North Carolina macular dystrophy

Page 668

North Carolina macular dystrophy is a very rare non-progressive condition. It was first described in families living in the mountains of North Carolina and subsequently in many unrelated families in other parts of the world.

1 Inheritance is AD with complete penetrance but highly variable expressivity with the gene MCDR1 on 6q16.
2 Grading and prognosis
a Grade 1 is characterized by yellow-white, drusen-like peripheral (Fig. 15.33A) and macular deposits which develop during the 1st decade and may remain asymptomatic throughout life.
b Grade 2 is characterized by deep, confluent macular deposits (Fig. 15.33B). The long-term visual prognosis is guarded because some patients develop neovascular maculopathy (Fig. 15.33C) and subretinal scarring.
c Grade 3 is characterized by coloboma-like atrophic macular lesions (Fig. 15.33D) associated with variable impairment of visual acuity.
image

Fig. 15.33 North Carolina macular dystrophy. (A) Peripheral flecks; (B) confluent macular flecks; (C) early neovascular maculopathy; (D) coloboma-like macular lesion

(Courtesy of P Morse)

Familial dominant drusen

Familial drusen (Doyne honeycomb choroiditis, malattia leventinese) is thought to represent an early-onset variant of age-related macular degeneration.

1 Inheritance is AD with full penetrance but variable expressivity. The gene EFEMP1 is on 2p16-21.
2 Signs in chronological order.
Asymptomatic yellow-white, elongated, radially-orientated drusen at the macula develop in the 2nd decade.
They may involve the disc margin and extend nasal to the disc.
With age the lesions become more numerous and acquire a honeycomb pattern (Fig. 15.34A).
Visual symptoms may occur in the 4th–5th decades due to RPE degeneration (Fig. 15.34B), geographic atrophy and occasionally CNV.
3 Investigations
a FA shows hyperfluorescence of the lesions that may be more numerous (Fig. 15.35A and B) than seen clinically (Fig. 15.35C and D).
b ERG is normal.
c EOG is subnormal in patients with advanced disease.
Page 669
image

Fig. 15.34 (A) Familial dominant drusen; (B) with RPE degeneration

(Courtesy of Moorfields Eye Hospital)

image

Fig. 15.35 Familial dominant drusen. (A and B) FA shows more numerous lesions than seen clinically (C and D)

(Courtesy of C Barry)

Sorsby pseudoinflammatory dystrophy

Sorsby pseudoinflammatory macular dystrophy, also referred to as hereditary haemorrhagic macular dystrophy, is a very rare condition that results in bilateral visual loss in the 5th decade of life.

1 Inheritance is AD with full penetrance but variable expressivity, with the gene TIMP3 is on 22q12.13.
2 Presentation is in the 3rd decade with nyctalopia or sudden visual loss due to exudative maculopathy in the 5th decade.
3 Signs in chronological order:
Yellow-white, confluent, drusen-like deposits along the arcades, nasal to the disc and mid-periphery (Fig. 15.36A).
Severe visual loss occurs due to exudative maculopathy secondary to CNV (Fig. 15.36B) and subretinal scarring (Fig. 15.36C).
Peripheral chorioretinal atrophy may occur by the 7th decade and result in loss of ambulatory vision.
4 ERG is initially normal but may be subnormal in late disease.
5 Prognosis is universally poor.
image

Fig. 15.36 Sorsby pseudoinflammatory macular dystrophy. (A) Confluent flecks nasal to the disc; (B) exudative maculopathy; (C) subretinal scarring in end-stage disease

(Courtesy of Moorfields Eye Hospital – fig. B)

Benign concentric annular macular dystrophy

1 Inheritance is AD.
2 Presentation is in adult life with very mild impairment of central vision.
Page 670
3 Signs. Bull’s eye maculopathy associated with slight vascular attenuation but a normal disc.
4 VF shows a paracentral ring scotoma.
5 FA shows an annular RPE window defect.
6 Prognosis is good in the majority of cases although a minority develop progressive loss of visual acuity and nyctalopia.

Central areolar choroidal dystrophy

1 Inheritance is AD with the gene locus on 17p although linkage to other genes has been described.
2 Presentation is in the 3rd–4th decades with gradual impairment of central vision.
3 Signs in chronological order:
Non-specific foveal granularity.
Well-circumscribed RPE atrophy and loss of the choriocapillaris at the macula (Fig. 15.37A).
Slowly expanding geographic atrophy with prominence of large choroidal vessels (Fig. 15.37B and C).
4 Prognosis is poor with severe visual loss occurring by the 6th or 7th decade.
image

Fig. 15.37 Progression of central areolar choroidal dystrophy. (A) Early; (B) intermediate; (C) end-stage

Dominant cystoid macular oedema

1 Inheritance is AD with the gene locus on 7p.
2 Presentation is in the 1st–2nd decades with gradual impairment of central vision.
3 Signs. Bilateral cystoid macular oedema.
4 FA shows a flower-petal pattern of leakage at the fovea.
5 Prognosis is poor because the oedema does not respond to treatment with systemic acetazolamide and geographic atrophy inevitably ensues.

Sjögren–Larsson syndrome

Sjögren–Larsson syndrome is a neurocutaneous disorder characterized by congenital ichthyosis, spasticity, convulsions and mental handicap with reduced life expectancy. The basic metabolic defect is deficient activity of fatty aldehyde dehydrogenase.

1 Inheritance is AR with gene locus on 7p11.
2 Presentation is with photophobia and poor vision.
3 Signs
Bilateral, glistening yellow-white crystalline deposits at the macula (Fig. 15.38) which appear during the first 2 years of life and become more numerous with time.
The presence of the macular lesions is thought to be a cardinal and perhaps pathognomonic sign of the syndrome.
Other features include cataract, colobomatous microphthalmos and pigmentary retinopathy.
3 VEP is abnormal.
image

Fig. 15.38 Macular crystals in Sjögren–Larsson syndrome

(Courtesy of D Taylor and C S Hoyt, from Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus, Elsevier Saunders 2005)

Familial internal limiting membrane dystrophy

1 Inheritance is AD.
2 Presentation is in the 3rd–4th decades with visual loss.
3 Signs. The posterior pole manifests a glistening inner retinal surface (Fig. 15.39).
4 ERG shows a selective diminution of the b-wave.
5 Prognosis is poor with severe visual loss occurring by the 6th decade due to retinoschisis, retinal oedema and retinal folds.
image

Fig. 15.39 Familial internal limiting membrane dystrophy

(Courtesy of J Donald M Gass, from Stereoscopic Atlas of Macular Diseases, Mosby 1997)

Generalized choroidal dystrophies

Choroideremia

Choroideremia is a progressive, diffuse degeneration of the choroid, RPE and retinal photoreceptors.

1 Inheritance is XLR with the locus on Xq21.2 (CHM gene).
Page 671
2 Female carriers show mild, patchy peripheral RPE atrophy and mottling (Fig. 15.40). However, visual acuity, peripheral fields and ERG are usually normal although some carriers may complain of nyctalopia. It is important to identify carriers because:
50% of their sons will develop choroideremia.
50% of their daughters will also be carriers of the disease.
3 Presentation is in the 2nd–3rd decades with nyctalopia, followed some years later by loss of peripheral vision.
4 Signs
Mid-peripheral RPE abnormalities that may, on cursory examination, resemble RP.
Atrophy of the RPE and choroid spreads peripherally and centrally (Fig. 15.40B).
End-stage disease shows a few large choroidal vessels coursing over the bare white sclera, vascular attenuation and optic atrophy. In contrast to primary retinal dystrophies, the fovea is spared until late (Fig. 15.40C).
5 ERG. Scotopic is non-recordable; photopic is severely subnormal.
6 FA shows filling of the retinal and large choroidal vessels but not of the choriocapillaris. The intact fovea is hypofluorescent and is surrounded by hyperfluorescence due to an extensive window defect (Fig. 15.40D).
7 Prognosis is very poor; although most patients retain useful vision until the 6th decade, very severe visual loss occurs thereafter.
image

Fig. 15.40 Choroideremia. (A) Female carrier; (B) advanced disease; (C) end-stage disease; (D) FA shows an intact fovea

(Courtesy of K Nischal – fig. B; S Milewski – figs C and D)

Gyrate atrophy

Gyrate atrophy is a metabolic disorder caused by a mutation of the gene encoding the main ornithine degradation enzyme, ornithine aminotransferase. Deficiency of the enzyme leads to elevated ornithine levels in the plasma, urine, CSF and aqueous humour.

1 Inheritance is AR with the gene locus on 10q26.
2 Presentation is in the 1st–2nd decades with myopia and nyctalopia.
3 Signs
Mid-peripheral depigmented spots associated with diffuse pigmentary mottling may be seen in asymptomatic cases.
Sharply-demarcated circular or oval areas of chorioretinal atrophy that may be associated with numerous glistening crystals at the posterior pole (Fig. 15.41A).
Coalescence of atrophic areas and gradual peripheral and central spread (Fig. 15.41B).
The fovea is spared until late (Fig. 15.41C).
Extreme attenuation of retinal blood vessels.
Vitreous degeneration and early-onset cataracts are common.
4 FA shows sharp demarcation between the choroidal atrophy and normal filling of the choriocapillaris.
Page 672
Page 673
Page 674
5 ERG is subnormal is early disease and later becomes extinguished.
6 Treatment. There are two clinically different subtypes of gyrate atrophy based on response to pyridoxine (vitamin B6), which may normalize plasma and urinary ornithine levels. Patients who are responsive to vitamin B6 generally have a less severe and more slowly progressive clinical course than those who are not. Reduction in ornithine levels with an arginine-restricted diet is also beneficial.
7 Prognosis is generally poor with legal blindness occurring in the 4th–6th decades from geographic atrophy, although vision may fail earlier due to cataract, CMO or epiretinal membrane formation.
image

Fig. 15.41 Gyrate atrophy. (A) Early disease; (B) advanced disease; (C) end-stage disease with preservation of the fovea

Generalized choroidal dystrophy

1 Inheritance is AD.
2 Presentation is in the 4th–5th decades with central visual loss or nyctalopia.
3 Signs
Mild pigment mottling at the posterior pole followed by atrophy of the RPE and choriocapillaris.
Severe chorioretinal atrophy that spreads gradually and until it involves virtually the entire fundus (Fig. 15.42).
4 ERG is subnormal.
5 Prognosis is poor because of early macular involvement.
image

Fig. 15.42 Generalized choroidal dystrophy

Progressive bifocal chorioretinal atrophy

1 Inheritance is AD with the gene locus on 6q.
2 Presentation is at birth.
3 Signs in chronological order
A focus of chorioretinal atrophy temporal to the disc which extends in all directions.
A similar lesion develops nasally.
The end result manifests two separate areas of chorioretinal atrophy separated by a normal segment (Fig. 15.43).
4 Prognosis is poor because macular involvement is inevitable.
image

Fig. 15.43 Progressive bifocal chorioretinal atrophy

(Courtesy of Moorfields Eye Hospital)

Vitreoretinal dystrophies

Juvenile X-linked retinoschisis

Pathogenesis

Juvenile retinoschisis is characterized by bilateral maculopathy, with associated peripheral retinoschisis in 50% of patients. The basic defect is in the Müller cells, causing splitting of the retinal nerve fibre layer from the rest of the sensory retina. This differs from acquired (senile) retinoschisis in which splitting occurs at the outer plexiform layer.

Diagnosis

1 Inheritance is XL with the implicated gene designated RS1 on Xp22.1-22.2.
Page 675
2 Presentation is between the ages of 5–10 years with reading difficulties due to maculopathy. Less frequently the disease presents in infancy with squint or nystagmus associated with advanced peripheral retinoschisis, often with vitreous haemorrhage.
3 Foveal schisis
‘Bicycle wheel’ radial striae radiating from the foveola associated with cystoid macular changes (Fig. 15.44A).
Over time the striae become less evident leaving a blunted foveal reflex.
4 Peripheral schisis predominantly involves the inferotemporal quadrant. It does not extend but may undergo the following secondary changes:
The inner layer, which consists only of the internal limiting membrane and the retinal nerve fibre layer, may develop oval defects (Fig. 15.44B).
In extreme cases, the defects coalesce, leaving only retinal blood vessels floating in the vitreous (‘vitreous veils’) (Fig. 15.44C).
Peripheral silver dendritic figures (Fig. 15.44D), vascular sheathing and pigmentary changes are common.
Nasal dragging of retinal vessels and retinal flecks may be seen.
5 Complications include vitreous and intra-schisis haemorrhage, neovascularization, subretinal exudation (Fig. 15.45A), and rarely retinal detachment and traumatic rupture of foveal schisis (Fig. 15.45B).
6 Prognosis is poor due to progressive maculopathy. Visual acuity deteriorates during the first two decades and may remain stable until the 5th–6th decades when further deterioration occurs.
7 OCT is useful for documenting progression of maculopathy (Fig. 15.46).
8 ERG is normal in eyes with isolated maculopathy. Eyes with peripheral schisis show a characteristic selective decrease in amplitude of the b-wave as compared with the a-wave on scotopic and photopic testing (Fig. 15.47).
9 EOG is normal in eyes with isolated maculopathy but subnormal in eyes with advanced peripheral lesions.
10 FA of maculopathy may show mild window defects but no leakage.
image

Fig. 15.44 Juvenile retinoschisis. (A) ‘Bicycle wheel’-like maculopathy; (B) inner leaf defect; (C) ‘vitreous veils’; (D) peripheral dendritic lesions

(Courtesy of K Slowinski – fig. A; C Barry – figs B and C; Moorfields Eye Hospital – fig. D)

image

Fig. 15.45 Complications of juvenile retinoschisis. (A) Traumatic hole in macular schisis; (B) subretinal exudation

(Courtesy of K Slowinski – fig. A; G-M Sarra – fig. B)

image

Fig. 15.46 OCT of macular schisis shows cyst-like changes

(Courtesy of J Talks)

image

Fig. 15.47 ERG in peripheral juvenile retinoschisis shows selective decrease of the b-wave amplitude

Stickler syndrome

Stickler syndrome (hereditary arthro-ophthalmopathy) is a disorder of collagen connective tissue. Inheritance is AD with complete penetrance but variable expressivity. Stickler syndrome is the commonest inherited cause of retinal detachment in children.

Classification

1 STL1 is the most common, maps to 12q13.11-q13.2, and is the result of mutations in the COL2A1 gene. These subjects have the classic ocular and systemic features as originally described by Stickler.
2 STL2 maps to 1p21 and is caused by mutations in the COL11A1 gene. These subjects have congenital non-progressive high myopia, sensorineural deafness, and other features of Stickler syndrome type 1.
3 STL3 maps to 6p21.3 and is due to mutations in the COL11A2 gene. These subjects have the typical systemic features, but no ocular manifestations.

Systemic features

1 Facial anomalies include mid-facial hypoplasia, depressed nasal bridge, short nose, anteverted nares and micrognathia (Fig. 15.48A).
2 Oral anomalies include cleft and high-arched palate (Fig. 15.48B), and bifid uvula.
3 Skeletal involvement includes relatively mild spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia, and joint hypermobility that decreases with age but may be followed by osteoarthritis in the 3rd–4th decades. Occasional findings include slender extremities with arachnodactyly that must not be confused with Marfan syndrome.
4 Deafness that may be caused by recurrent otitis media or due to sensorineural defect.
Page 676
Page 677
image

Fig. 15.48 Stickler syndrome. (A) Facial appearance; (B) cleft and high-arched palate

(Courtesy of K Nischal – fig. B)

Ocular features

1 Presentation is in early childhood with high non-progressive myopia.
2 Signs
In STL1 patients exhibit an optically empty vitreous, a retrolenticular membrane and circumferential equatorial membranes that extend a short way into the vitreous cavity (membranous type 1 vitreous – Fig. 15.49A).
In STL2 patients the vitreous has a fibrillary and beaded appearance (fibrillary type 2 vitreous).
Radial lattice-like degeneration associated with RPE hyperplasia, vascular sheathing and sclerosis (Fig. 15.49B).
Retinal detachment develops in approximately 50% in the first decade of life, often as a result of multiple or giant tears that may involve both eyes.
Regular screening is mandatory so that retinal breaks can be treated prophylactically.
3 Associations
a Presenile cataract characterized by frequently non-progressive peripheral cortical ‘wedge’ or ‘fleck’ opacities is common.
b Ectopia lentis is uncommon.
c Glaucoma occurs in 5–10% of cases and is associated with a congenital angle anomaly.
image

Fig. 15.49 Stickler syndrome. (A) Vitreous liquefaction and membranes; (B) radial lattice degeneration and pigmentary changes

Wagner syndrome

Wagner syndrome (erosive vitreoretinopathy) shows similar vitreous changes to Stickler syndrome but is not associated with systemic abnormalities.

1 Inheritance is AD with the gene locus on 5q12-q14.
2 Presentation is in early life with pseudostrabismus due to congenital temporal displacement of the fovea with a positive angle kappa, and nyctalopia.
3 Signs
Low myopia (−3.00 or less).
The vitreous is optically empty with complete absence of normal scaffolding (Fig. 15.50A).
Avascular greyish-white preretinal membranes extending from the posterior pole to the periphery (Fig. 15.50B).
Progressive chorioretinal atrophy (Fig. 15.50C)
4 FA shows non-perfusion due to gross loss of the choriocapillaris (Fig. 15.50D).
Page 678
5 ERG may initially be normal and then shows reduction of scotopic b-wave amplitudes and diffuse cone-rod loss.
6 Complications include cortical cataracts in the 4th decade, peripheral tractional retinal detachment in about 50% of patients older than 45 years of age, and occasionally glaucoma.
7 Prognosis is poor.
image

Fig. 15.50 Wagner syndrome. (A) Vitreous liquefaction; (B) peripheral chorioretinal atrophy and preretinal membranes; (C) progressive chorioretinal atrophy; (D) FA shows gross loss of the choriocapillaris

(Courtesy of E Messmer)

Familial exudative vitreoretinopathy

Familial exudative vitreoretinopathy (Criswick–Schepens syndrome) is a slowly-progressive condition characterized by failure of vascularization of the temporal retinal periphery, similar to that seen in retinopathy of prematurity, but not associated with low birth weight and prematurity.

1 Inheritance is AD and rarely XLR or AR, with high penetrance and variable expressivity.
2 Presentation is in late childhood.
3 Signs
Vitreous degeneration and peripheral vitreoretinal attachments associated with areas of ‘white without pressure’.
Abrupt termination of peripheral retinal vessels in a scalloped pattern at the temporal equator.
Peripheral vascular tortuosity, telangiectasia (Fig. 15.51A) and neovascularization.
Fibrovascular proliferation and vitreoretinal traction resulting in ridge formation (Fig. 15.51B).
Progressive peripheral fibrovascular proliferation (Fig. 15.51C)
Vascular straightening and temporal ‘dragging’ of the macula and disc (Fig. 15.51D).
4 Complications include tractional retinal detachment during the first decade, subretinal exudation that may become massive (Fig. 15.51E), vitreous haemorrhage, cataract and neovascular glaucoma.
5 FA shows peripheral retinal non-perfusion and highlights straightening of blood vessels (Fig. 15.51F).
6 Prognosis is poor although in some cases peripheral retinal laser photocoagulation or cryotherapy may be beneficial. Vitreoretinal surgery for retinal detachment, whilst difficult, may be successful in selected cases.
image

Fig. 15.51 Familial exudative vitreoretinopathy. (A) Peripheral telangiectasia; (B) fibrovascular ridge; (C) fibrovascular proliferation; (D) ‘dragging’ of the disc and macula; (E) subretinal exudation; (F) FA shows vascular straightening and abrupt termination

(Courtesy of C Hoyng – fig. E)

Enhanced S-cone syndrome and Goldmann–Favre syndrome

There appears to be an overlap between these two conditions, and it is believed that the latter may represent a more severe variant of the former.

1 Inheritance is AR with variable expressivity. The gene implicated is NR2E3 at 15q23.
2 Presentation is with nyctalopia in childhood.
3 Signs
Pigmentary changes along the vascular arcades or mid-periphery that may be associated with round pigment clumps in more advanced case (Fig. 15.52A)
Cystoid maculopathy without fluorescein leakage, or schisis (Fig. 15.52B).
Vitreous degeneration and peripheral retinoschisis in Goldmann–Favre.
4 ERG. The human retina has three cone photoreceptor types: short-wave sensitivity (S-), middle-wave sensitivity (M-) and long-wave sensitivity (L-). Most inherited retinal dystrophies exhibit progressive attenuation of rods and all classes of cones. However, enhanced S-cone syndrome is unique because it is characterized by hyperfunction of S-cones and severe impairment of M- and L-cones, and non-recordable rod functions.
Page 679
5 Prognosis is poor because the condition is progressive.
6 Differential diagnosis.
Retinitis pigmentosa.
Congenital retinoschisis.
image

Fig. 15.52 Enhanced S-cone and Goldmann–Favre syndrome. (A) Severe pigment clumping; (B) macular schisis and pigmentary changes along the arcade

(Courtesy of D Taylor and CS Hoyt, from Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus, Elsevier Saunders 2005 – fig. A; J Donald M Gass, from Stereoscopic Atlas of Macular Diseases, Mosby 1997 – fig. B)

Snowflake vitreoretinal degeneration

1 Inheritance is AD with the gene locus on 2q37.
2 Signs (Fig. 15.53)
Stage 1 shows extensive areas of ‘white-without-pressure’ in patients under the age of 15 years.
Stage 2 shows snowflake-like, yellow-white spots in areas of ‘white with pressure’ in patients between 15 and 25 years.
Stage 3 manifests vascular sheathing and pigmentation posterior to the area of snowflake degeneration in patients between 25 and 50 years.
Stage 4 is characterized by increased pigmentation, gross vascular attenuation, areas of chorioretinal atrophy, and less prominent snowflakes in patients over the age of 60 years. The macula and disc remain normal.
Other signs include mild myopia, vitreous fibrillary degeneration and liquefaction, a dysmorphic optic nerve head and corneal guttae.
4 Complications include retinal break formation, retinal detachment and presenile cataract.
5 ERG shows low scotopic b-wave amplitude.
6 Prognosis is usually good.
image

Fig. 15.53 Snowflake degeneration

Dominant neovascular inflammatory vitreoretinopathy

1 Inheritance is AD mapped to 11q13.
2 Presentation is in the 2nd–3rd decades with vitreous floaters due to vitritis.
Page 680
Page 681
3 Signs
Panuveitis.
Peripheral vascular closure and pigment migration.
Peripheral and then disc neovascularization.
Epiretinal and subretinal fibrocellular membranes.
4 Complications include vitreous haemorrhage, tractional retinal detachment, cystoid macular oedema, cataract and neovascular glaucoma.
5 ERG shows selective loss of b-wave amplitude.
6 Prognosis is guarded. Peripheral retinal photocoagulation and vitreous surgery may be required to preserve vision.

Dominant vitreoretinochoroidopathy

1 Inheritance is AD; maps to the BEST1 gene on 11q13.
2 Presentation is in adult life if symptomatic, but frequently the condition is discovered by chance.
3 Signs
Fibrillary vitreous degeneration and cells.
A non-progressive or very slowly progressive encircling band of pigmentary disturbance between the ora serrata and equator with a sharply defined posterior border.
Within the band there is arteriolar attenuation, neovascularization, punctate white opacities and later chorioretinal atrophy.
4 Complications, which are uncommon, include cystoid macular oedema, vitreous haemorrhage and cataract.
5 ERG is variably reduced.
6 EOG is subnormal with a reduced Arden ratio.
7 Prognosis is good.

Kniest dysplasia

1 Pathogenesis. Defect in the type II collagen gene, COL2A1, also involved in Stickler syndrome type 1.
2 Inheritance is AD but most cases represent a fresh mutation.
3 Systemic features. Flat face, enlarged joints, platyspondyly and disproportional short stature; neonates display short, stiff limbs and have apparently large heads.
4 Ocular features include high myopia, vitreous degeneration, retinal detachment and ectopia lentis.

Albinism

Introduction

Page 682

Albinism is a genetically determined, heterogeneous group of disorders of melanin synthesis in which either the eyes alone (ocular albinism) or the eyes, skin and hair (oculocutaneous albinism) may be affected. The latter may be either tyrosinase-positive or tyrosinase-negative. The different mutations are thought to act through a common pathway involving reduced melanin synthesis in the eye during development. Tyrosinase activity is assessed by using the hair bulb incubation test, which is reliable only after 5 years of age. Patients with albinism have an increased risk of cutaneous basal cell and squamous cell carcinoma that usually occurs before the fourth decade.

Tyrosinase-negative oculocutaneous albinism

Tyrosinase-negative (complete) albinos are incapable of synthesizing melanin and have white hair and very pale skin (Fig. 15.54A) throughout life with lack of melanin pigment in all ocular structures.

1 Inheritance is usually AR; the condition is genetically heterogeneous.
2 Signs
a VA is usually <6/60 due to foveal hypoplasia.
b Nystagmus is typically pendular and horizontal. It usually increases in bright illumination and tends to lessen in severity with age.
c The iris is diaphanous and translucent (Fig. 15.54B), giving rise to a ‘pink-eyed’ appearance (Fig. 15.54C).
d The fundus lacks pigment and shows conspicuously large choroidal vessels. There is also foveal hypoplasia with absence of the foveal pit and lack of vessels forming the perimacular arcades (Fig. 15.54D).
e The optic chiasm has fewer uncrossed nerve fibres than normal so that the majority of fibres from each eye cross to the contralateral hemisphere. This can be demonstrated by visual evoked potential which shows predominance in the response to monocular stimulation.
f Other features commonly seen include high refractive errors of various types, positive angle kappa, squint and absence of stereopsis.
Page 683
image

Fig. 15.54 Tyrosinase-negative oculocutaneous albinism. (A) White hair and very pale skin; (B) marked iris translucency; (C) ‘pink eye’ appearance; (D) severe fundus hypopigmentation and foveal aplasia

(Courtesy of L Merin – fig. D)

Tyrosinase-positive oculocutaneous albinism

Tyrosinase-positive (incomplete) albinos synthesize variable amounts of melanin. The hair may be white, yellow or red and darkens with age. Skin colour is very pale at birth but usually darkens by 2 years of age (Fig. 15.55A).

image

Fig. 15.55 Tyrosinase-positive oculocutaneous albinism. (A) Fair hair and normal skin colour; (B) mild fundus hypopigmentation

(Courtesy of B Majol – fig. A)

Ocular features

1 Inheritance is usually AR with at least two gene loci.
2 Signs
a VA is usually impaired due to foveal hypoplasia.
b Iris may be blue or dark-brown with variable translucency.
c Fundus shows variable hypopigmentation (Fig. 15.55B).

Associated systemic syndromes

1 Chediak–Higashi syndrome
Inheritance is AR with the gene locus on 1q42.
Mild oculocutaneous albinism.
Leucocytic abnormalities resulting in recurrent pyogenic infections.
The vast majority of patients eventually develop a lymphoproliferative syndrome (accelerated phase) characterized by fever, jaundice, hepatosplenomegaly, pancytopenia and bleeding that requires bone marrow transplantation.
Prognosis for life is generally poor with demise in the 2nd decade.
2 Hermansky–Pudlak syndrome is a lysosomal storage disease of the reticuloendothelial system.
Inheritance is AR.
Mild oculocutaneous albinism.
Platelet dysfunction resulting in early bruising.
Pulmonary fibrosis, granulomatous colitis and renal failure in some cases.
3 Waardenburg syndrome is an AD condition of which there are four types.
The main systemic features are white forelock, cutaneous hypopigmentation, poliosis, sensorineural deafness (particularly in type 2), and synophrys or an unusual hair distribution. Upper limb defects, flexion contractures and syndactyly in type 3 and neurological anomalies in type 4.
Ocular features include lateral displacement of the medial canthi (not present in type 2), broad nasal bridge, hypochromic irides with segmental or total heterochromia (Fig. 15.56), and segmental or total choroidal depigmentation.
image

Fig. 15.56 Waardenburg syndrome with iris heterochromia and synophrys

Ocular albinism

Involvement is predominantly ocular with normal skin and hair although occasionally hypopigmented skin macules may be seen.

1 Inheritance is usually XL and occasionally AR with multiple gene loci identified.
2 Female carriers are asymptomatic although they may show partial iris translucency, macular stippling and mid-peripheral scattered areas of depigmentation and granularity (Fig. 15.57).
3 Affected males manifest hypopigmented irides and fundi.
image

Fig. 15.57 Carrier of XL ocular albinism

Cherry-red spot at macula

Pathogenesis

Page 684

A cherry-red spot at the macula (Fig. 15.58) is a clinical sign seen in the context of thickening and loss of transparency of the retina at the posterior pole. The fovea, being the thinnest part of the retina and devoid of ganglion cells, retains relative transparency, allowing persistent transmission of the underlying highly vascular choroidal hue. This striking lesion occurs in the sphingolipidoses, which comprise a group of rare inherited metabolic diseases characterized by the progressive intracellular accretion of excessive quantities of certain glycolipids and phospholipids in various tissues of the body, including the retina. The lipids accumulate in the ganglion cell layer of the retina, giving the retina a white appearance. As ganglion cells are absent at the foveola, this area retains relative transparency and contrasts with the surrounding opaque retina. With the passage of time the ganglion cells die and the spot becomes less evident. The late stage of the disease is characterized by degeneration of the retinal nerve fibre layer and consecutive optic atrophy. The following diseases are associated with a cherry-red spot.

image

Fig. 15.58 Cherry-red spot at the macula

GM1 gangliosidosis (generalized)

1 Inheritance is AR.
2 Defect. Deficiency of beta-galactosidase 1.
3 Systemic features include coarse facies, stiff joints, growth deficiency and severe cerebral degeneration leading to death by the age of 2 years.
4 Ocular features are macular cherry-red spot in 50% of cases and very subtle corneal clouding.

Mucolipidosis type I (sialidosis)

1 Inheritance is AR.
2 Systemic
a Late-onset (after the age of 7 years) with myoclonus and seizures, compatible with normal life span.
b Severe starts before the age of 2 years and is characterized by severe neurodegeneration Hurler-like facies, hepatosplenomegaly, deafness, severe neurodegeneration and death in early childhood.
3 Ocular features include corneal clouding, macular cherry-red spot, optic atrophy and occasionally punctate lens opacities.

GM2 gangliosidosis

Tay–Sachs disease

1 Inheritance is AR.
2 Pathogenesis. Deficiency of hexosaminidase A leads to accumulation of GM2 ganglioside in the brain and retina.
3 Systemic features are progressive neurological deterioration starting within 6 months or birth with death by 2–4 years.
4 Ocular features include a macular cherry-red spot that is present by 3 months and optic atrophy after 1 year, with blindness by the age of 2 years.

Sandhoff disease

1 Inheritance is AR.
2 Pathogenesis. Hexosaminidase A and B deficiency.
3 Systemic features. Neurological degeneration similar to Tay–Sachs disease.
4 Ocular features are macular cherry-red spot and early-onset blindness.

Niemann–Pick disease

Page 685

There are three main types of Niemann disease (A–C) but only the first two are associated with a cherry-red spot. The main ocular features of type C (chronic neuropathic) are gaze palsy and abnormal eye movements.

Type A (acute neuronopathic)

1 Inheritance is AR.
2 Systemic features present in infancy and are characterized by severe psychomotor deterioration, massive hepatosplenomegaly and death by the 4th year.
3 Ocular features are macular cherry-red spot in 50% and subtle corneal clouding.

Type B (chronic non-neuronopathic)

1 Inheritance is AR.
2 Systemic features present in the teenage years or early adulthood and are characterized by hepatosplenomegaly, and involvement of lungs and bone marrow. CNS disease does not occur and survival for up to 20 years after presentation is possible.
3 Ocular features are macular cherry-red spot and bull’s eye maculopathy.

Farber disease

1 Inheritance is AR.
2 Pathogenesis. Lysosomal storage disease due to defective ceramidase.
3 Systemic features include hoarseness, aphonia, dermatitis, lymphadenopathy, psychomotor retardation, and renal and cardiopulmonary disease.
4 Ocular features include macular cherry-red spot, pingueculum-like conjunctival lesions and nodular corneal opacity.
Page 686