2 The theoretical foundation for frequency-specific microcurrent
After 12 years of clinical use, thousands of anecdotes, hundreds of patient and practitioner testimonials, one blinded placebo-controlled trial in animals showing unprecedented reductions in lipoxygenase mediated inflammation and biochemical data in humans reporting unheard of reductions in inflammatory cytokines all in response to only very specific frequency combinations and current flow, it is clear that there is some sort of frequency-specific effect on biological tissue created by pulse trains and microamperage current.
No one who has experienced FSM either as a patient or practitioner has any question that there is some sort of frequency-specific effect. Tissues soften and change state in seconds, scar tissue appears to dissolve, inflammation disappears, injuries heal, endorphins increase and patients get euphoric all at remarkable rates. But how are these effects created? There needs to be some intellectually satisfying explanation that describes how microamperage current increases cellular energy by 500% and how one frequency combination, and only one frequency combination, reduces inflammation in a blinded placebo-controlled animal trial by 62% in four minutes.
Physics describes the electromagnetic composition and function of matter; bio-physics describes the electromagnetic structure and function of biological systems. Chemistry describes the characteristics and bonds that hold atoms and molecules together and describes the reactions that alter those bonds to create new molecules; the science of biochemistry does the same for biological systems. Physics and chemistry, and their biological-science siblings, provide the basic information and conceptual framework that explains how frequency-specific microcurrent probably creates its effects.
Physics has two branches that study in detail the structure, properties and function of matter. Classical or Newtonian physics describes the behavior of physical objects on a macroscopic scale. Classical physics describes and can predict with certainty the behavior of large collections of particles such as the metal beams, hinges and glass lenses used to construct the Hubble telescope. But classical physics is not sufficient to describe the behavior of very small systems such as the atoms, molecules, black holes and streams of energy that the telescope observes in the voids of space.
Quantum physics studies the submicroscopic forces that shape our universe at the atomic level. Quantum theory states that energy is not continuous but comes in discrete packets or quanta. These quanta behave like particles having mass at some times but they behave as waves of energy without mass at other times depending on the circumstances. Quantum physics must deal with uncertainty because the position and the momentum of a particle cannot be known at the same time and quantum phenomena, while coherent, are inherently unpredictable. Quantum physics is relevant at the atomic scale describing the behavior of atoms, molecules, electrons and protons. In the new field of quantum biology, electrons from green tea’s anti-oxidant catechins have been observed tunneling instantaneously across a gap between molecules to bind and inactivate a free radical, a process forbidden in classical physics (Anderson 2009).
Classical physics provides accurate descriptions of the properties of the body as a large collection of particles but only quantum physics can provide a model for our internal submicroscopic structure and function. Our bodies appear as solid objects that have all of the properties described by Newtonian physics. We have mass, momentum, inertia, and obey the law of gravity. But we are at the same time an electromagnetic system with all of the properties described by quantum physics. We are as much energy as we are matter. This is not an esoteric or spiritual appreciation of the human condition; it is simply basic physics.
The principles of both classical and quantum physics are simultaneously true for large collections of particles such as the human body. Electrons in the outer orbital of a hydrogen atom that is attached to a carbon atom in a collagen strand in your forearm are no different than the hydrogen atoms whizzing around the linear accelerator at Fermi Labs in Chicago, Illinois. Electrons may have different energy states because of their relationship to nearby atoms but the electron itself has the same basic structure. A proton is a proton but the resonant frequency of a proton, for example, depends on a property known as the Larmor frequency, which will be different for protons in different tissues due to the proximity of other nearby atoms. If your body represented the nucleus of a hydrogen atom, the nearest electron would be one quarter mile away and would appear as a potential in space into which the energy of the electron could materialize as a charged particle under appropriate conditions. We, our bodies, are in fact more space than they are matter. And all of that space and all of that matter is electro-magnetic and electro-biochemical in nature.
Using frequencies and current to successfully modify the structure and function of biological tissue brings the FSM practitioner to a practical appreciation of this quantum reality. One of the basic principles of science is that you cannot throw out the data because it doesn’t match the model of how the system was thought to operate. When new data appears then the model has to change to allow for it. The first time one specific frequency combination and 100μamps of pulsed direct current caused scarred muscles to elongate and soften permanently; the author’s model for how biological systems operate changed forever.
The model that follows is an attempt to explain in fairly simple terms how it is that the observed affects of FSM are created. It is a rough approximation and by no means complete or thoroughly understood but it is what can be proposed given our current level of knowledge.
There are at least four factors operating simultaneously to create the effects seen with the use of Frequency-specific Microcurrent.
1. Current: The microamperage direct current alone produces specific well documented and predictable effects.
2. Frequencies: Two frequencies are used simultaneously, one from each channel, and produce specific effects that are independent of the current applied.
3. The Human Biological Semiconductor: The electromagnetic nature of biological tissue provides a semi-conductor tissue matrix that mediates the response to both the current and the frequencies.
4. Stable State: And finally the patient’s general physical and emotional health, conditioning, diet, hydration and history create an environment that will either support or erode the changes created by the frequencies and the current in any given treatment or any course of treatments.
Trial and error and clinical experience has shown that appropriate current levels, contact placement and current polarity are essential to successful FSM treatments, especially when treating pain. Larger and more muscular patients require higher current levels. Children and frail patients require smaller current levels. When treating the viscera or the central nervous system, current flow doesn’t seem that important; the treatment appears to affect the target tissue whether the contacts are positioned so the current flows through it or not. How does the current facilitate the treatment?
All matter, living and non-living, is ultimately an electromagnetic phenomenon (Becker 1985). All atoms are bonded electrically and all bonds are ultimately electromagnetic because the electrons creating the bonds are in constant motion and moving electrons create a magnetic field. The material world is a collection of atomic structures held together by electromagnetic forces.
Biological tissue is made up of complex combinations of atoms and molecules creating the membranes, organelles and cells that determine physical structure and physiologic function. Every cell and tissue membrane has an electrical potential or charge difference between one side of the membrane and the other (Kirsch 1998). Furthermore, the body as a whole has an electromagnetic field created by charge differentials between one area and another. The human system is more positively charged at the top near the head and along midline at the spine and more negatively charged in the periphery. Becker established that the bioelectric field produced by these linked electrical potentials is responsible for intracellular communication and tissue repair and eventually he proposed that the electromagnetic field controls all life processes (Becker 1985).
All living systems have an electrical component whose existence is now well established but whose function is still not completely understood. The following basic principles of electronic circuitry apply to all biochemical, bio-electric living systems.
Current is created by the movement of electrons from one point to another using some conducting medium. The electron is a negatively charged particle that moves in, or is likely to be found in, a particular volume, called an orbital around the positively charged nucleus of an atom. Electrons have mass when measured as a particle but have only energy when measured as a wave. Energy and matter are actually interchangeable in all matter. For our purposes the electron is the basic unit of charge that moves in any circuit including the human bio-electric circuit.
Amperage describes the number of electrons moving past a fixed point in a unit of time; it is the amount of current flowing. Current is measured in amperes or amps.
Voltage is the measure of pressure or push behind the electrons flowing in a circuit and is measured in volts.
Resistance to current flow is measured in ohms and is determined by factors that inhibit current flow.
Circuit: To have current flow you need a circuit. Current is introduced in one spot, flows through a conductor and eventually gets back to the generator by way of some conductor.
Water flowing through a garden hose is the classic analogy used to describe these circuitry concepts. The amount of water flowing through the garden hose corresponds to the amperage or current, how many gallons per minute come out of the end of the hose. The water pressure corresponds to the voltage, how much water pressure is there behind the stream driving the water out of the hose. The size of the hose or any impediment to the flow of water corresponds to the resistance. A smaller hose, or even a larger hose with a tangle of fiberglass webbing in the line, will have more resistance to water flow.
In the garden hose circuit analogy, water is made available by the municipal water district and conducted through a series of pipes to the garden hose. The garden hose delivers some total amount of water to the lawn that is determined by the water pressure, the size of the hose and the amount of time spent watering. Some of the water is absorbed by the grass and, combined with sunlight, turns into the energy that makes the grass grow; some of it evaporates, goes into the clouds and returns to the municipal water district in the form of rain; and some of it percolates through the ground into the aquifer and returns to the wells used by the water district. The water or current is produced someplace, travels to someplace and does something and then returns to the source to complete the circuit.
This relationship between voltage, current and resistance is described in Ohm’s law, Voltage = Current × Resistance (V = I × R). If the voltage stays the same and the resistance goes up then the current will go down. If the current must be kept constant then the voltage must increase if the resistance increases. If one parameter changes it automatically changes at least one other parameter.
Microcurrent devices used in FSM treatments are “constant current generators”. The machine increases the voltage automatically as needed, up to a maximum of about 30 volts, in order to keep the current constant and push the desired amperage through the body’s resistance.
Resistance to current flow is created by anything that interferes with conductivity or that acts as an insulator. Blood, water, collagen and lymph all conduct electricity; oil, scar tissue and inflammation resist current flow. Total resistance in a human body is determined by fluid content or lack of it, general health and inflammation, muscle mass, amount of oil on the skin, adipose and hydration.
Current flowing through the body fuels all biological process. Gnok Cheng (Cheng et al 1982) and his associates demonstrated that applying additional current to a biological system could increase both protein synthesis and energy production dramatically as long as the current was small enough. Direct current levels of 50 to 1000μamps applied across rat skin increased glycine (amino acid) transport by 75% compared with untreated controls and current levels of 500μamps increased aminoisobutyric acid (amino acid) uptake by 90% indicating a dramatic increase in protein synthesis. But current levels above 1000μamps decreased protein synthesis by as much as 50%.
Box 2.1 The direct relationship between voltage (V), resistance (I) and current (C)
Microcurrent devices are constant current generators. The voltage will increase as needed to maintain the current level that has been set as long as the resistance is low or stays constant. Eventually if the current requirement is increased enough the voltage will not be able to increase sufficiently to maintain current levels and the percent conductivity shown on the machine will decrease.
If the resistance (I) increases, for example when a patient is dehydrated or when the conducting medium has too much resistance, the voltage (V) must increase to keep the current (C) constant at the level the machine has been set to deliver. If the resistance increases past a certain point, the voltage will not be able to increase sufficiently to maintain the current level. And the percent conductivity shown on the machine will decrease. The percentage of current conducted will return to 100% if the current level set on the machine is reduced or if the resistance decreases.
If the current is set to very high levels of 300–400μamps, as it is when treating athletes, the voltage can compensate as long as the resistance stays low. This need to reduce resistance may explain why athletes need to be more hydrated than the average patient. It also suggests that the combination of graphite gloves wrapped in wet towels may be a very low resistance conducting medium since it is so effective in conducting the higher levels of current required for athletes and heavier patients.
ATP (adenosine triphosphate) is the chemical energy molecule that fuels every biological process. Direct current levels between 100 and 500μamps applied to rat skin increased ATP levels by three to five times (300% to 500%). Current exceeding 1000μamps caused ATP production to level off and currents above 5000μamps reduced ATP levels as compared to untreated controls. Once the external current was discontinued the ATP production and amino acid transport levels returned to baseline; there was no residual effect in rat skin.
Cheng and his colleagues hypothesized that the increased number of electrons from the DC current flowing along the mitochondrial membranes increased the proton gradient across the membrane thereby increasing ATP production. Oschman (2009) has proposed that the electron transport chain in mitochondria can become electron-deficient, and that microcurrent provides more electrons that are semiconducted through the living matrix to the mitochondrial membranes. In either case, the additional ATP available is probably responsible for the increase in protein synthesis. There have been no studies that demonstrate increased ATP production in a living system but the increases in healing seen with microamperage current are usually attributed to this increase in ATP production and protein synthesis. Cheng and colleagues did not attempt to explain why current levels over 1000μamps reduced ATP production and protein synthesis. It is worth noting that all electrical stimulation devices except microcurrent use current levels above 1000μamps and may be decreasing ATP production, although that has not been demonstrated.
It has been proposed that Voltage Gated Ion Channels (VGICs) may also be affected by the current flow along or across the membrane but no one has measured changes in these transport proteins in response to externally applied microamperage current. VGICs transport ions such as sodium, potassium, calcium and others across the cell membrane and control virtually all cellular processes. VGICs require ATP activation to change configuration allowing them to transport their ion across the cell membrane. There has been some suggestion that microcurrent and the voltage pushing it along or across membranes has a direct affect on the VGICs but there is no data to support this hypothesis. The current could be altering VGIC function simply because it increases ATP production.
Whatever the mechanism, current clearly has an influence on treatment. Clinical trial and error has determined that the current must be polarized positive with the positive leads at the spine and the negative leads at the distal end of the nerve for the successful treatment of nerve pain. The treatment for fibromyalgia associated with spine trauma and for post-stroke central pain is most successful when the current is polarized positive with the positive leads at the neck and the negative leads at the feet. Some patients respond better to polarized positive current for all applications and some patients do better with pulsed alternating DC current. In any FSM course, roughly half of the students being treated during a practicum session respond better to polarized current and the other half respond better to alternating DC current. No explanation is offered for this observation but any model for the biological effects of pulsed DC current must be able to explain the observations.
Figure 2.1 • ATP is produced when electrons, stripped off of food substrate, flow through an electron transport cascade and also flow along the cell membrane creating a difference in charge between one side of the membrane and the other. The charge gradient pulls protons across a membrane and ATP is produced. Increased current flow up to 500μamps increases ATP production. Current flow above 1000μamps overwhelms the system and decreases ATP production.
Current levels must be appropriate to the patient’s size and muscle mass for successful treatment of muscle pain and scar tissue. A larger or more muscular person requires higher current levels than a smaller, deconditioned or frail person. If the current levels are too low, response to treatment is slow or equivocal. There is almost no detectable response when 100μamps are used to treat a 250 pound professional football player but increasing the current to 400μamps creates an immediate positive response to the same frequencies. A small frail deconditioned patient will respond well to 100μamps and will find 400μamps irritating and bothersome. A very ill patient may find anything more than 20μamps irritating or too stimulating.
These observations dictate the treatment parameters discussed in this text but there is nothing specific in microcurrent theory or research to explain these phenomena.
Current flow alone creates some positive effect but the most dramatic effects of FSM occur in response to specific frequencies. The frequency to neutralize a condition is delivered on one channel. The frequency for the tissue being addressed is delivered simultaneously on a second channel. In a blinded placebo controlled trial in mice, one frequency combination, 40Hz on channel A (reduce inflammation), and 116Hz on channel B (the immune system) reduced arachidonic acid induced lipoxygenase (LOX) mediated swelling in the mouse’s ear by 62% in four minutes. The ear swelling was measured with mechanical calipers and recorded in millimeters. Three unrelated frequency combinations (new injury, remove mineral from bone, and .3Hz) tested in the same model had no effect on inflammation or swelling. According to the researcher who performed the tests, no prescription or non-prescription drug has ever reduced inflammation in this animal model by more than 45% (Reilly et al 2004).
In a subsequent trial measuring reductions in COX mediated inflammation, 40Hz (reduce inflammation) and 116Hz (immune system) reduced swelling and inflammation by 30% which is identical to the prescription injectable anti-inflammatory Toridol when it was tested in this same mouse model. But 40Hz on channel A (reduce inflammation) and 355Hz (skin) on channel B had no anti-inflammatory effect and was equivalent to placebo (Reilly 2005). This suggests that the pattern created by both frequencies used is responsible for the anti-inflammatory effect, as long as one of the frequencies is 40Hz. The frequency from the second channel has a definite impact.
Figure 2.2 • The bar on the left is the normal swelling at 11 units seen when arachidonic acid is painted on a mouse ear and measured with calipers. The bar in the center represents the reduction in swelling to 4 units seen when the mice were treated with 40Hz and 116Hz for four minutes. The bar on the right is the swelling at 10 units seen when a sham frequency was applied for four minutes. This is a time-dependent response; half of the effect is present at two minutes and the full effect is present at four minutes.
The response in mice was time dependent – one half of the response was present at 2 minutes and the full response was present at 4 minutes. Further time spent on the frequency had no additional positive effect. Why and how is the reduction in inflammation time dependent?
In a clinical setting, fibromyalgia patients whose fibromyalgia was associated with spine trauma responded only to the frequencies 40Hz on channel A (reduce inflammation) and 10Hz on channel B (the spinal cord), even when they didn’t know what treatment was being done and had no expectations that anything would help them. This frequency combination, and only this frequency combination (40/10), reduced pain from 7.4/10 to 1.4/10 and reduced all of the inflammatory cytokines at logarithmic rates by factors of 10 to 20 times in 90 minutes. Interleukin 1 decreased from 392pg/ml down to 21pg/ml in 90 minutes, TNF-α was reduced from 299pg/ml down to 21pg/ml, and IL-6 went down from 204pg/ml to 15pg/ml. Medical cytokine researchers report that cytokines are difficult to change and change slowly when they can be made to change at all, making this data all the more remarkable and challenging to explain.
Figure 2.3 • Interleukin 1 normal range is 0–25 pg/ml. IL-1 started at 392 and dropped to 21.4 in 90 minutes in response to one specific frequency combination, 40Hz on channel A and 10Hz on channel B in patient MK. For five patients the average IL-1 of 330 ± 39 reduced to 80 ± 31pg/ml. IL-6, TNF-α, IFN-γ, CGRP all changed at similar rates. Medical cytokine researchers report that cytokines are difficult to change and change slowly when they can be made to change at all. This is a time-dependent response taking 60–90 minutes for the full effect to be achieved.
The response in fibromyalgia patients is also time dependent. Roughly half of the effect is present at the end of 45 minutes and the full effect is present at 90 minutes. Treating for more than 90 minutes doesn’t improve the outcome. Treating for less than 60 to 90 minutes is unsatisfactory. Why and how is the reduction in inflammation and pain time dependent?
Scar tissue responds only to specific frequency combinations that cause the tissue to elongate and soften dramatically allowing increases, even doubling, of range of motion within 10 to 20 minutes. If the scar tissue is very dense or very chronic the process requires more time and repeated treatment but is usually successful. The frequency to reduce inflammation does nothing for scar tissue; the frequency for removing scar tissue does nothing to reduce inflammation. Regardless of the condition being treated, when the frequency is correct the patient and the practitioner can often feel a sensation of warmth underneath the skin contact as the tissue begins to soften.
Figure 2.4 • 1Hz as a sine wave is a single cycle passing a point in space every second. A 1Hz square wave with the same amplitude or height contains high frequency harmonics to create the single pulse but it still represents only one cycle per second. The amplitude is measured from the peak to the valley. Larger amplitude waves have more energy than smaller amplitude waves.
How could a frequency create these observed changes? Why does the area being treated get warm just before the tissue changes? Why and how is the reduction in inflammation time dependent?
First let’s define some basic terms and concepts.
Frequency: Frequencies refer to the number of pulses of sounds or electrons moving through a conducting medium in one second. Frequencies are measured in hertz. One hertz is a single waveform or cycle passing a fixed point in one second. In engineering terms, the word “frequency” should only be used when referring to the pulse produced by a sine wave which has no harmonics. Microcurrent devices usually output square wave pulses containing a large number of high frequency harmonics instead of using sine waves because the clinical effects were found to be better with square waves. A square wave frequency of 40Hz is technically a pulse train of 40Hz – 40 square waves that pass a point in space every second.
Even though it is a pulse train and not a sine wave the word frequency still accurately describes the number of pulses per second regardless of the high frequency harmonics in the pulse. A middle C note played on the piano will sound different than middle C played on a violin or a flute because of the difference in harmonics but the note played is still middle C.
Figure 2.5 • Square waves that deliver the current in microcurrent devices are actually ramped square waves. The leading edge of the wave can have a steep slope giving it more “impact” when it encounters the target tissue or it can have a gradual increase to the peak amplitude creating a gentle wave slope. The sharp waveslope is more effective in chronic conditions but can be irritating on newly injured tissue. The gentle waveslope is more comfortable in acute injuries presumably because the current increases gradually giving the injured membrane time to incorporate the additional current flow.
Amplitude: The size of a wave as measured from the peak to the valley. Larger amplitude waves have more energy than smaller waves.
Waveslope: Waveslope describes the shape of the leading edge of the wave form. The FSM microcurrent devices use a ramped square wave to deliver the current and form the frequency pulse because it was thought to overcome skin resistance more effectively. The leading edge of the square wave may be more acute forming a sharp edged wave form or it may be a more gradual slope allowing the current to build up more slowly. A sharp waveslope is used to treat chronic pain but is irritating in new injuries. A gentle waveslope is more comfortable in new injuries. This observation has not been explained.
The frequencies create tissue changes by resonance. Resonance is the tendency of a system to oscillate at larger amplitudes in response to some frequencies and not others. Every mechanical system and every chemical bond has a resonant frequency. At the resonant frequency even small driving forces can produce very large amplitude vibrations. These large amplitude vibrations can cause the system to oscillate so violently that it comes apart. Mechanical resonance destroyed the Tacoma Narrows Bridge when the resonant frequency of the bridge was matched by the frequency of oscillations in the bridge caused by the wind during a rain storm. The resulting violent pendulum effect tore the bridge apart and created a most memorable visual example of the power of resonance.
Acoustic resonance shatters a lead crystal glass when the musical note being played matches the resonant frequency that binds the lead atoms together in the crystal matrix. The resonance causes the atomic bonds to oscillate, like the Tacoma Narrows Bridge, and the glass comes apart. Resonant phenomena occur with every type of vibration or wave and every type of bond and structure.
If every chemical bond and every physical structure has a binding energy that holds it together and has a resonant frequency that will cause it to oscillate, then it is possible to imagine that a resonant frequency exists for every bond that will cause oscillations sufficiently violent to weaken or break the bonds that hold the structure together.
As the bonds began to vibrate, the fluids in the surrounding area would become warm from the friction of the vibration much as your hands become warm when you rub them together on a cold night. This warming response to vibration could explain why the tissue being treated feels warm when the frequency is correct and appropriate.
Think of scar tissue as a physical structure made of collagen that is wound up tight and coiled in on itself like a rubber band that has been twisted to operate the propeller of a toy airplane. The coiled scar tissue is held together in this configuration by cross linked bonds that keep it shortened and tight. Think of the collagen coil cross-links as the bonds in the lead crystal glass. When the frequencies are used that seem to dissolve scar tissue, the scarring begins to soften almost immediately and over the next few minutes the tissue elongates and continues to soften until it feels almost normal and the range of motion has increased. Once the bonds break that hold the coils tight, the collagen unwinds and as it elongates the cross-link binding sites are separated and cannot reconnect. In general, once scar tissue dissolves it doesn’t return.
When scar tissue dissolved in one particular burn patient, this meant that he could bend his fingers enough to hold a coffee cup for the first time in the three years since his injury. Patients who have been burned develop severe scar tissue that limits range of motion and activity and is resistant to every other type of therapy. Range of motion was measured in seven patients by occupational therapists at Mercy St. John’s Medical Center in Springfield Missouri on a Monday in 2003. The patients were treated with FSM for one hour each day for the next three days and measured again on Friday. Every patient treated had statistically significant increases in range of motion that lasted through the four weeks of follow-up and were assumed to be permanent (Huckfeldt et al 2003).
Figure 2.6 • The collagen in scar tissue is wound tight in coils that are cross linked to hold them in place. It is possible that the frequencies resonate with the bonds holding the cross links in place and break them allowing the collagen to elongate and the scar tissue to soften and lengthen. Once the scar tissue elongates the binding sites don’t match up and the scar tissue doesn’t reform. This model attempts to demonstrate one possible mechanism by which the observed effects could be created.
Think of Interleukin 1 and the other inflammatory cytokines as the Tacoma Narrows Bridge. The frequency may resonate with one or more crucial bonds that hold inflammatory peptides together in the crystalline structure that makes them act as a mediator of inflammation. The resonant vibration and oscillations from the frequency could weaken and eventually change or break the bond that holds the cytokine in its shape causing the peptide to change configuration. The changed conformation means that the peptide no longer fits into the receptors in the cell membrane that create the effects of inflammation. The de-configured peptide would not be recognized as a cytokine by immunochromatography and the levels would drop dramatically as they did in the fibromyalgia study.
This would account for the rate and degree of reductions in cytokine levels. Any other mechanism that has been considered doesn’t explain the rate of reductions in measurements of cytokine levels in blood or in mean ear swelling in mice. The time required to shatter the bonds could account for the time dependent nature of the response seen in the mouse research. The vibration of the bonds during the oscillation phase could account for the warmth felt as the frequency begins to create an effect.
All that is required for resonant phenomenon to operate in a biological system is bonds that resonate and a conducting medium to convey specific frequency patterns. We are immersed in a sea of electromagnetic signals that form environmental electronic white noise from television and cell phone signals to light bulbs and 60 cycle wall current. While Becker makes a good case for their general negative effects on the immune and autonomic nervous system they don’t appear to have immediate specific effects on specific conditions (Becker 1990).
But coherent frequency patterns delivered in conjunction with current that increases cellular energy production could reasonably be expected to create a resonant effect. “Living matter is highly organized and exceedingly sensitive to the information conveyed by coherent signals” (Oschman 2000). There are protein receptors in the cell membrane that mediate all of the functions of the cell. Cellular biologist Bruce Lipton points out that even when the nucleus is removed cells can still perform their normal functions perfectly for up to 30 days through the actions of the membrane proteins embedded in the cell wall operating in a co-ordinated self-directed fashion in response to environmental signals. These membrane proteins are sensitive to electromagnetic signals, as well as neurotransmitters, hormones, nutrients, toxins and oxidative stress and even emotions or thoughts (Lipton 2008). Drugs and nutrients act like a key in a lock to change the configuration of cell membrane proteins and thereby change cell functions. A coherent frequency pattern could change cell membrane protein configuration and cellular function like the key beeper that opens your car door lock from 20 feet away.
Figure 2.7 • Cell membrane proteins carry out all basic cellular activities and can be influenced by medications or nutrients acting like keys in a lock to change protein configuration and function. The membrane proteins can also be influenced by frequencies acting like the “key beeper” that opens the lock at a distance with an electromagnetic signal.
This model doesn’t explain why the reductions in inflammation stop when the levels get into the normal range. It doesn’t account for why the patients with spinal cord inflammation only responded to 40Hz (reduce inflammation) and 10Hz (spinal cord) but did not respond to the frequencies to reduce inflammation (40Hz) in the immune system (116Hz) that reduced inflammation in the mice. But it is a start and provides something that can be tested when the research opportunity presents itself.
These two frequencies “reduce inflammation” and “reduce scarring” are easy to conceptualize and it is relatively easy to measure scar tissue and inflammation and changes created by treatment. But there are other frequencies presented in this text that are less amenable to measurement and may be difficult for some to even conceptualize. How does one measure the “fact of trauma”, or “toxicity” or “allergy reaction” or the “emotional component” of a patient’s condition? There are frequencies in this text for each of these pathologies or conditions that might affect any given tissue.
There may never be objective evidence that these frequencies are doing what they are alleged to do but that doesn’t prevent us from employing, enjoying and documenting the clinical effects. Does the patient feel warmth when the frequency is used? Does the tissue soften when the frequency is used? Does the condition, range of motion or the pain change when the frequency is used? These clinical effects in response to a correct frequency have been observed consistently in different settings and until objective evidence is available these observations form a basis for future research.
When a frequency is applied it either has a positive effect or it has no effect at all. If there is nothing for it to resonate with the frequency appears to pass on through the tissue with no discernible effect. The analogy of unlocking your car door with your electronic key beeper illustrates this phenomenon. When your car is parked in a crowded parking lot, it is only your car door that unlocks when you press the button that sends the electronic signal from your key fob to open the lock. The frequency from your car key resonates with your car only, and not with any others. In a similar fashion, the frequency chosen to treat a particular condition in a particular tissue appears to do that and nothing else. So, in general, there is no harm in trying a frequency for a particular condition / tissue combination.
But the response to certain frequency effects has been sufficiently powerful that the entire process must be approached with both humility and respect. For all of the disclaimers and caveats included in this text the author has learned through experience that the frequencies actually do what they are alleged to do (in a hydrated patient).
For example the body uses inflammation to control infection. The frequency to “reduce inflammation” does indeed reduce inflammation and when this frequency is used in a patient who has an infection that the doctor does not suspect, the infection will become more symptomatic in a very short time when the frequency is used. The bad news is that the infection becomes precipitously worse; the good news is that this predictable response is diagnostic and leads to appropriate treatment of an infection that was previously occult.
And good intentions will not prevent a frequency from having its effect. When Dr. Hawks left the clinic in 1997 and started her practice in Minnesota, it was thought that the frequency 81Hz described on Van Gelder’s list as “secretions” would normalize secretions. Dr. Hawkes spent an hour treating a young girl for the lung congestion of cystic fibrosis and at the end of the hour the patient’s lungs were completely clear. Thinking that 81Hz would “normalize” the lung secretions Dr. Hughes used it at the end of the treatment. The lungs became re-congested in less than 10 seconds. Knowing that they needed to explore this affect, they took a short break, repeated the original treatment and cleared the lungs again. At the end of this treatment the frequency 81Hz was not used and the child’s lungs stayed clear for about two weeks. Dr. Hughes’ called the clinic immediately to report this new understanding; 81Hz was found to increase secretions rather than normalize secretions.
It is worth noting that the intention to normalize secretions did not prevent the frequency from increasing secretions. Experiences such as these have created profound respect for the effect of the frequencies. It is safest to assume that the frequencies will do what they are alleged to do and think ahead to what will happen when the effect occurs.
All science starts with observation. This is what we observe. The condition changes; the glove gets warm; the pain is reduced. Then science has to ask, “Is it reproducible or just a coincidence?” In any hydrated patient with the same symptoms and physical examination, treated by any practitioner with knowledge, skill and the correct diagnosis will the treatment produce the same response? So far experience suggests that the affects are reproducible. Then science asks if the response is predictable. If you know the appropriate diagnosis and the treatment can you predict the patient’s response? If you use the treatment response as a diagnostic indicator will the patient response to treatment help clarify the diagnosis? Once again experience suggests that the response is predictable.
Still, it must be said that the descriptions for the frequency effects are just a model for what the frequency is thought to do and appears to do. Until there is more research to document that the observed change corresponds to removal of the pathology specified by the frequency and that it happens in the tissue specified by the frequency, any claims must be approached with caution. This caveat should not deter the thoughtful practitioner from taking advantage of the apparent effects. Medicine used aspirin as an anti-inflammatory and anti-pyretic for hundreds of years before its mechanism of action and effects on prostaglandin chemistry were known.
In order for the current and frequencies to have an effect on living tissue there has to be some conductor that conveys the current and the frequencies and mediates the observed responses. The human body is that conductor.
Insulators: Insulators do not conduct current and serve to stop its flow. In the garden hose circuit analogy the plastic exterior of the hose itself is an insulator – the water stays inside the hose. The plastic coating on electrical wire or the ceramic stand-off separating the wire and the pole are insulators as long as the voltage and current are appropriate to the material in the insulator.
Conductors: To continue with the garden hose analogy for current, voltage and resistance, the different types of conductors can be thought of as being different types of garden hoses. Water, copper wire, metal foil and graphite are all conductors we use every day.
Metallic conductors conduct current as a cloud of electrons moving rapidly along the surface of a metal wire providing the electricity for light and power to our homes.
Ionic conductors use positively and negatively charged inorganic ions to create current. Ions are charged particles released when a salt like sodium chloride dissolves in water creating positively charged sodium ions and negatively charged chloride ions. The charged ions dissociate from the parent molecule and flow through a medium or across a membrane to create balance and a net zero charge. Even water, H2O, ionizes to some extent creating H+ and OH− ions that balance out to a net zero charge in its liquid form.
Living organisms create ion gradients by actively pumping charged ions to different sides of a membrane using voltage gated ion channels (VGICs) to make one side of the membrane positively charged and the other side relatively negative in charge. Organisms use these ionic gradients and the difference in charge between one side of the membrane and the other to power certain cellular processes.
Three sodium ions are pumped from the inside of the cell to the outside of the cell for every two potassium ions that are pumped from outside the cell to the inside to maintain a charge difference across the membrane. The negatively charged proteins inside the cell combine with the smaller number of positively charged potassium ions to make the inside of the cell −70 mV more negative than the outside of the cell. Each transfer of sodium and potassium across the membrane consumes one ATP molecule.
This voltage gradient is maintained at some physiologic expense and is used to power numerous cellular functions.
Ionic currents die out after short distances and travel just across the distance of the membrane making them unsuitable for long distance transmission. The ionic potential across a cell membrane can depolarize and reverse temporarily and then repolarize, creating a wave that moves along the neuron (the action potential). This creates a form of long distance communication but the ionic current itself at any given moment travels only the short distance across the membrane.
Semiconductors are halfway between conductors like metal and insulators like plastic, rubber or ceramic. Semiconductors are materials having an orderly molecular structure like crystals in which electrons can move easily from the electron cloud around one atomic nucleus to the cloud around another, carrying small currents instantaneously over long distances. Crystalline semiconductors, like silicon and germanium in computer chips, are arranged in neat geometric lattices where electrons can move easily through the space in the lattice where there is no electron. Semiconductors are useful because current flows through them instantaneously over long distances without losing energy and can be used to transmit information depending on the flow pattern through the lattice matrix.
Albert Szent-Györgyi (1941, 1988) determined that the water molecules lining cell membranes, proteins and collagen form such a lattice matrix, sharing electrons and making “holes” that allow current to flow instantaneously through the body as in a semiconductor. In this water–protein semiconductor matrix, electrons and holes can carry energy and information much more rapidly than the energy and information stored in chemical bonds in slowly diffusing molecules such as ATP and hormones. The semiconductor matrix can also transfer information much faster than nerve impulses.
Direct or DC current is a unidirectional steady flow of current (electrons) that travels from the source through a conductor or semiconductor to the load and back again to the source forming a DC circuit. Direct current is used to charge batteries and in nearly all electronic systems as the power supply because it is simple and direct.
Figure 2.8 • The sodium potassium pump that maintains cell membrane potential is an example of an ionic current. Three sodium ions are pumped to the outside of the membrane and two potassium ions are pumped to the inside of the membrane where they combine with the more negatively charged intracellular proteins to make the inside of the membrane −70mV more negative than the outside. This charge differential drives many cellular processes.
Analog systems take into consideration the whole gradient of intensity of information available to them. They therefore can detect and transmit a broader spectrum of information than digital systems. However, analog systems are slower than digital systems, which only sample information in bits that are strong enough to reach a certain pre-set threshold. Digital systems can transfer information longer distances without loss or distortion, and can process information in a wide variety of ways, as in a digital computer. Analog computers were used before digital computers, and were much slower and had much less functional flexibility. When a voice is recorded in an analog system all of the vibrations are impressed on the tape in a continuous stream of information which can be reproduced in the same continuous stream. No decoding is required. The perineureum, the glial membranes surrounding the nerves, carry continuous and complete information as well as pulsing direct currents in an analog system from the brain to the periphery and in the opposite direction (Becker 1985).
Digital systems use on/off–all-or-none signals to encode information and they can be very precise. Digital recordings take the continuous stream of the human voice and break it into tiny on/off impulses that can be manipulated and decoded to provide information we call sound. The brain and nervous system are the best example of a biological digital system. Nerve impulse action potentials are on/off digital pulses which encode signals between the brain and the periphery for rapid information transfers seen in thought, movement and sensation.
Alternating or AC current as delivered in the United States builds up voltage which is positive on top of the wave form and negative on the bottom pushing current through the system. The voltage source falls off and then changes direction back and forth – as long as current is moving in one direction or the other the object being powered will operate. The cycle repeats itself endlessly with the wave-form reversing polarity 60 times a second in the US to create what we know as “60 cycle house current”. Alternating current has advantages over direct current for distribution that make it a better choice for transporting large amounts of power over long distances and it is the type of current used to power our homes.
Nerve impulses are a good example of AC current in the body. The action potential is an on/off spike carrying an impulse down a nerve that then repolarizes to be ready for the next discharge. The AC action potential allows the nervous system to operate like a computer, transferring and interpreting large amounts of information very rapidly by using a digital on/off data transfer and storage system.
In his 1985 book, The Body Electric, Robert Becker described his experiments on limb regeneration in salamanders. He concluded that the perineureum or glial membrane covering nerves serves as a primitive analog, direct current semiconducting information system that facilitates tissue repair and regeneration.
The normal difference between the more positively charged salamander’s head (think of the brain as a battery) and his front leg is −10mV; the leg has more electrons than the head and is more negatively charged. When the salamander loses the limb to a predator (or to an orthopedic surgeon researcher such as Becker), the injured limb immediately becomes more positive, the current changes direction and electrons flow away from the injured site making it +20 mV more positive than the salamander’s head. This reversal of current was called the “current of injury”. Within a few days the current flow changes direction again and gradually becomes more negative as electrons flow into the injured area, presumably from the brain as battery, until it reaches −30mV. By the time the limb is completely regenerated at 25 days the charges are back to their baseline difference of −10mV between the head and the leg.
Figure 2.9 • Robert Becker demonstrated that the salamander and the human body are charged DC current systems. Humans and salamanders are more positively charged at the head and along the spine and more negatively charged distally at the ends of the arms and legs
(adapted with permission from Becker & Seldon 1985).
Frogs and mammals do not regenerate severed limbs in their normal state and Becker discovered that they do not show the same changes in current flow and polarity as the salamander. In frogs and mammals, the site of injury remains positively charged, and electron deficient, until scarring and healing have been completed. Becker was able to create limb regeneration in frogs and rats by using a battery attached to the head to artificially induce the same pattern of electron flow in these animals that exists in the salamander. The DC current flow was the key to limb regeneration as long as the perineureum was intact. If the perineureum was removed regeneration would not occur.
He was also able to facilitate repair of experimentally induced spinal cord injuries in cats by using direct current to keep the electrical potential negative, electron rich, in the injured spinal cord. The untreated cord goes into “spinal shock”, becomes electron deficient and electropositive and the normal course leads to a paraplegic outcome.
Through various ingenious experiments Becker eliminated every tissue except the analog direct current semiconducting perineural system as the source of information that directs regeneration and healthy tissue repair. The analog semiconductor properties of the perineureum are thought to be responsible for the remarkable results achieved when FSM is used to treat the nervous system.
The semiconductor nature of biological tissue creates some advantages and disadvantages for FSM treatments.
A head injury patient became dizzy in response to the frequency combination for “removing trauma” (94) from “the medulla” (94) when the contacts were placed at her neck (see Chapter 10). The dizziness resolved in a few minutes and when she felt normal again, she was asked to participate in an experiment. The contacts were placed at her knees and she was treated while sitting with the machine turned away so she could not tell what frequencies were being used. Four different combinations were tried for one minute each and each time the patient was asked how she felt. Each time she said she felt fine. As soon as the frequency combination 94Hz/94Hz was used, with the contacts at her knees, she became immediately dizzy and her eyes began to oscillate in a saccadic movement.
This response was interpreted to mean that the frequency for “removing trauma” from the “medulla” made this patient dizzy no matter where the contacts were placed but more importantly it meant that the frequency for “removing trauma” from “the medulla” would resonate with the medulla no matter where it was applied in the semiconductor matrix. The reaction to this frequency combination only occurs in a small percentage of patients who have a certain type of vestibular injury and its mechanism is not understood, but the reaction is so specific and characteristic that it is diagnostic. The implications of this discovery made it possible to treat the brain, through the semi-conductor matrix, by placing the contacts at the abdomen and back.
The disadvantages of this phenomenon dictate some of the precautions recommended in treatments discussed in the following chapters. The frequencies for removing scar tissue cannot be used any place in the body for six weeks after a new injury even if the current does not flow through the newly injured area. The body requires scar tissue to form in order to heal a new soft tissue injury. But, if the frequency to “remove scar tissue” will cause collagen cross links to vibrate and weaken by resonance, they will do so no matter where they are applied in the semiconductor matrix that is the body.
The patient’s general physical and emotional health, conditioning, diet, hydration and history create an environment that will either support or erode the changes created by the frequencies and the current in any given treatment.
“Stable state” is a term from thermodynamics meaning the ability of an energy system to maintain equilibrium and implies a state of balance. In a state of equilibrium there are no unbalanced driving forces within the system and the system can maintain its energy state. For example water is completely stable as ice as long as the surrounding environment is 0°C. If you add energy to the system so that the water becomes a liquid it is completely stable as a liquid as long as the surrounding environment is between 0°C and 100°C. If you add energy to the system so that the water becomes steam it will remain in a vapor state as long as the surrounding temperate is above 100°C. But if the surrounding atmosphere doesn’t support that state then the water molecules will drop back into the energy state that the system supports. It is the same with people; it is just more complicated.
In the human system the equilibrium is complex and dynamic and consists of physical, nutritional, biomechanical, emotional, neuro-endocrine, circulatory, neuromusculoskeletal and immunological factors that are affected by toxicity, allergies, chronic infections, disuse, misuse, trauma, scarring and other factors to mention what is certainly only a partial list.
Two patients presented to the clinic in the same week and their stories are the perfect illustration of the power of the stable state.
The first patient was a 54-year-old woman who worked as an executive secretary in a very high pressure company who presented with neck, shoulder and upper back pain of six years duration. She was a smoker of normal weight and height, eating a varied “normal” diet and did not enjoy exercise. She seemed tense, had a negative attitude about most things but did not consider herself to be depressed and was not being treated for depression. She presented with reduced cervical spine range of motion, multiple myofascial trigger points in all of the neck and shoulder muscles and pain of a 6–7/10 on a visual analog scale.
She was treated with FSM twice a week for six weeks. At the end of each treatment her pain was reduced from a 6/10 down to a 2/10. At the end of each treatment she was encouraged to drink more water to support tissue health and detoxification. She refused saying that she didn’t like water and preferred coffee or tea. She was encouraged to change her posture at work and take hourly brief breaks to do shoulder shrugs and upper body stretches. She refused saying that she did not have time to stretch in her high pressure job and no time or attention to spare for such frivolous things. She was asked to purchase a magnesium supplement either from the clinic or a nutrition center to help the muscles relax. She replied that she knew for sure that supplements were a useless waste and only helped the manufacturers and retailers make money.
For six weeks she left every treatment session with her pain reduced from a 6/10 to a 2/10 and every post-treatment conversation was a repeat of the last one and her pain always returned within two days. FSM could change the muscles and reduce the pain but when she left the treatment room there was nothing in her body or emotions to maintain the changes. The ice that melted during treatment and became liquid was plunged back into the frigid environment of her life style and turned back into ice within two days.
The contrast between this patient and a 48-year-old man who came in for treatment at about the same time was striking. The man was a student at the National College of Naturopathic Medicine, a very demanding medical training program in Portland, who presented with pelvic and hip pain of 30 years duration acquired when he ran hurdles in high school track competitions. He meditated daily and did Tai Chi and Qi gong regularly in spite of his sedentary student lifestyle, had a vegetarian macrobiotic diet, took supplements regularly and drank at least two quarts of filtered water per day. He glistened with health and seemed happy and content. He presented with reduced range of motion in the right hip, multiple myofascial trigger points in the hip and pelvic floor muscles and pain of a 5–6/10 on a visual analog scale.
His pain was reduced from 6/10 to 0/10 at the end of the first treatment. He returned for the second treatment with pain of a 2/10 and was again pain free at the end of the treatment. He canceled his third appointment because he had no remaining symptoms. We happened to meet in a grocery store one year later and he reported that his pain had never returned. His pain and muscle injury were more chronic than the secretary’s but he responded more quickly because of his overall health, attitude and life style. The ice in his muscles melted and remained permanently liquid in the balmy environment of his life.
Figure 2.10 • Water is used as an analogy for a human “stable state”. Water is completely stable as ice as long as the surrounding temperature is 0°C. It is stable as a liquid as long as the environment is between 0 and 100°C and stable as steam at 100°C and above. If the surrounding atmosphere doesn’t support the state then the water molecules will drop back into the energy state that the system supports. People are the same way; it’s just more complicated.
The stable state is the fourth component of any FSM treatment. The treatments described in this text predictably create remarkable changes in tissue, pain and function. But those changes have to be supported by the lifestyle, mental, physical, emotional and even spiritual milieu that is the patient’s life if they are to become permanent.
The rapid improvement in symptoms and function create not only pain reduction but hope and can encourage patient compliance because the exercises, lifestyle and diet modifications that seemed futile before now seem worth the effort.
The practitioner is encouraged to pursue any training in nutrition, biomechanics, exercise, reconditioning, emotional support, motivation, detoxification strategies and allergy management that seems useful and interesting. This information will bear fruit in creating a stable state that allow changes produced by FSM treatments to persist.
Box 2.3 Factors operating in each treatment
• The CURRENT increases in ATP and changes membrane protein function
• The FREQUENCIES resonates with pathologies and tissues to create changes
• The human SEMICONDUCTOR system that conveys information instantaneously throughout the body
• The STABLE STATE allows the changes to happen and helps them to persist
In every treatment each of these factors operates simultaneously and must be taken into consideration to some degree depending on the situation and the patient. The current increases ATP and changes protein synthesis and membrane protein function. The frequencies resonate with pathologies and tissues to create very specific predictable changes. The semiconductor matrix that conveys information throughout the body allows the effects of the frequencies to travel throughout the system. The stable state allows the changes to happen and helps them to persist and become permanent.
One of the basic principles of science is that you cannot throw out the data because it doesn’t match the model of how the system was thought to operate. When new data appears then the model has to change to allow for it. A new model for how the universe operates was required to explain the consistent, reproducible, and ultimately predictable changes observed with the application of frequencies and current to the human system.
This chapter is an incomplete model of the electromagnetic reality of human experience and should not be confused with the reality itself which is complex beyond imagining. It will take years to test, confirm or clarify the model and longer than that to appreciate the reality within which it operates, but in the meantime it aims to provide an intellectually satisfying framework that allows the practitioner reassurance in using the technique until a more complete understanding can be achieved.
Anderson M. Is quantum mechanics controlling your thoughts?. 2009. Discover Magazine, February 2009
Becker R.O., Seldon G. The body electric: electromagnetism and the foundation of life. New York: Quill, William Morrow, 1985.
Becker R.O. Cross currents. New York: Jeremy Tarcher/Penguin, 1990.
Cheng N., et al. The effect of electric currents on ATP generation, protein synthesis, and membrane transport in rat skin. Clinical Orthopedics. 1982;171:264-272.
Huckfeldt R., Mikkelson D., Larson K., et al. The use of micro current and autocatalytic silver plated nylon dressings in human burn patients: a feasibility study. 2003. Pacific Rim Burn Conference
Kirsch D.L., Lerner F.N. Electromedicine: the other side of physiology. Weiner R.S., editor. Pain management, a practical guide for clinicians, vol. 2. LLC Boca Raton Florida: CRC Press, 1998.
Lipton B. The biology of belief: unleashing the power of consciousness, matter and miracles, second ed. Carlsbad, CA: Mountain of Love Productions, Hay House, Inc, 2008.
Oschman J. Energy medicine, the scientific basis. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 2000.
Oschman J.L. Mitochondria and cellular aging. Klatz R., Goldman R., editors. Anti-aging therapeutics. vol. 11. Chicago IL: American Academy of Anti-Aging Medicine; 2009:185-194.
Reilly W., Reeve V.E., Quinn C. Anti-inflammatory effects of interferential, frequency-specific applied microcurrent. 2004. Proceedings of the Australian Health and Medical Research Congress
Reilly W., Reeve V.E. Private communication – unpublished data from mouse study. 2005.
Szent-Györgyi A. Towards a new biochemistry? Science. 1941;93:609-611.
Szent-Györgyi A. To see what everyone has seen, to think what no one has thought. Biol. Bull.. 1988;174:191-240.